Worn bits - I've had my fun

  • Thread starter Deleted member 35268
  • Start date
Page may contain affiliate links. Please see terms for details.

Ming the Merciless

There is no mercy
Location
Inside my skull
How many miles ago did you replace the chain? The trick with chains is to replace them before they wear the cassette and chain rings. It’s often cheaper to replace the chain a bit earlier than to wait till everything else is worn.

For the headset it’ll be the lower bearing assembly. Without mudguards, on wet days or riding through puddles / floods, you’ll get dirty water thrown up onto the lower bearings. Eventually it’ll get past the bearing seals and you’ll get a mix of old grease, water and mud. That’ll create a grinding paste and you’ll end up with stuff oozing out including bits of rust. Rust is likely the cause of the orange look. Mudguards avoid this problem, but understand not everyone like guards.

As above cranks, it’s likely the chain rings needing replacement. It’ll be the chain ring you use the most needs doing. Other one may be ok, but you won’t know till new chain on.

Derailleur with some cleaning and generous soaking or lubing can probably be freed up. They are simple mechanical affairs.

4,500 miles for a set of disc pads sounds reasonable. Get in the habit of checking remaining pad thickness reasonably regularly though. Them wearing out should not come as a complete surprise.

You need to decide if you want to do any of the work yourself. If so what, and do you want to buy the parts from the LBS? You likely won’t save on cost of parts (buying from LBS) if you do it yourself, but will save cost of labour, at expense of convenience.

A good tip after particularly wet rides is to just give the derailleurs and drivetrain a wipe with an oily rag. Then spray with a light oil. Spraying a rag then wiping just as effective. You can also do bolts if you wish.
 
Last edited:

Gunk

Guru
Location
Oxford
Replacing the whole rear derailleur seems a bit extreme, they’re really easy to strip and service, and unless it’s bent or the spring has failed, it should give decades of service. I’ve rebuilt 50 year old rear mechs and managed to get them functioning like new after about an hour of cleaning and just replacing the jockey wheels.

Sounds like it needs a chainring, some jockey wheels and a headset, £150 at the most. I would get a second opinion.
 

roubaixtuesday

self serving virtue signaller
I'll be round with my big spanner later.


574347
 

Sharky

Guru
Location
Kent
75p for a cup of tea? I can get a whole box of teabags for that
You can get a cup of tea for 75p - tell me where.

Never understand either when you have to pay more for a large cup of tea. It's the same single tea bag, just a little bit more water. I suppose there is a cost of more electricity and more on the water metre. But must be negible
 

HMS_Dave

Grand Old Lady
4500 miles in 2 years is approx 40 miles per week. One moderate or two short rides each weekend.
The assumption is that OP trashes his bike, then forgets about it till next weekend.
Most of that stuff should be given a quick once over every time the bike comes out.
The OP already addressed your assumptions. There is no need for doubling down on it...

The way i see it, there are plenty of other reason for excessive wear...
 
If as you say you don't trash your bike then I'm amazed at all the things wrong with it. Fair enough chain and cassette and possibly brakes. Are you a very powerful rider and do you do a lot of muddy tracks?
I would find the cost for 4500 miles excessive but then I do my own repairs.
 

weareHKR

Senior Member
The OP already addressed your assumptions. There is no need for doubling down on it...

The way i see it, there are plenty of other reason for excessive wear...
lol... he's just posting for reactions, needs a clip round the ear... :laugh::laugh:😉
 
OP
OP
D

Deleted member 35268

Guest
OK, here goes. The bike is back home.

Headset - I am going to see how the seals are, clean it up, grease it and see if it will do. I will get the part ID while removed. I have replaced Giant headsets before. These can be £25-30

Front chainrings - The outer ring is sharky on inspection, the inner one less so. I will replace the chain and cassette first and see if it is a mare. I can replace the chainrings easy enough. about £40-50 for the outer

Chain and Cassette - I will get a new KMC 10 speed chain and Shimano 10 speed cassette - I can fit this. Just need to order some parts. £12 for the chain, £25 for the cassette

Rear gearing - jockey wheels are fine, the Mech does swivel and move OK but it is very dirty. When I try and shift from smallest cog to anything bigger from the brifter it is not functioning - it pulls and clicks. With the mech being stiff perhaps the cable has been compromised. I need to take it apart for a closer look. I also see no reason to replace the mech. I do not like the tiagra shifters on these bikes, they are really hard to work on. I also have the nasty hydaulic converter on the handlebars (see https://www.giant-bicycles.com/gb/defy-advanced-3-2018)

Read brake pad, easy, just slots in, I have a spare.

My tyres need replacing too.

I'm saving about £70 on labour.

Yes, it needs a bit of love.
 
Top Bottom