TYRES
I'm beginning to believe that you actually need two different tyres because one type is good for going up steep hills and another for the flatter rides. It seems to make a lot of difference. For going up hills you really need to be able to get out of the saddle at speeds below 10mph. On the tyre I used today it would just spin on the roller. Todays tyre was a low friction high power tyre ideal for the a flat ride like Simcoe. Had I had on my trainer tyre that has no slip at all on the up-hills, the result would have probably been very different.
Also tyre pressures. When I've had punctures on the trainer and believe it or not, I've had quite a few, it gets very hard to pedal well before you feel the bump bump and realise you have a flat. Tonight I was running at 130psi as its far more important than out on the street due to the contact patch being much smaller. So need to run very high pressures to avoid excess friction.
Adam. I think your sticky up-hill tyre is no use for the fast flat rides.