Next week patient-facing health workers who've not yet been vaccinated against COVID-19, for whatever reason, will need their first jab (to allow for an 8 week gap to their second) if they are to carry on in such a role. There are various arguments.
- The policy of mandatory vaccination for healthcare workers goes against 'bodily autonomy' [It's doesn't.]
- The policy is contrary to the ethical principle of informed consent. [Nope, not that either.]
- Healthcare workers who refuse to be vaccinated are coerced to have the vaccination. [coercion with a small 'c'. Even if such description is reasonable, the question remains: is it morally justified?]
- The policy will lead to a mass exodus of staff, which will damage the healthcare system and patient care [Maybe - figures available. Other countries offer an idea of the extent of this. There will a deadline cohort, hoping the policy will be abandoned.]
- There is no evidence that vaccination stops infection or transmission. [Mmmm]
Effectiveness of vaccine against Omicron infection and transmission still tbc. UK HSA (20 Jan): "several studies have provided evidence that vaccines are effective at preventing infection" and that, since uninfected people cannot transmit the virus, "the vaccines provide some protection against transmission". The report noted: "There may be additional benefit, beyond that due to prevention of infection, if some of those individuals who become infected despite vaccination are also at a reduced risk of transmitting (for example, because of reduced duration or level of viral shedding)."
There is strong evidence that the vaccine is effective against serious illness / hospital admission. US CDC data suggests that vaccinated adults aged 18 to 49 are 12x less likely to be admitted to hospital than the unvaccinated.
For 50 to 64s, the likelihood of hospital admission is 44 times less (US CDC). UK ONS figures suggest that the likelihood of developing long COVID-19 is 41% lower for the doubly-vaccinated.
So vaccinated healthcare workers who nevertheless get infected with COVID-19 are less likely to be absent from the 'front line' for a prolonged period than their non-vaccinated counterparts, easing pressure on the NHS.