Are we being forced to go electric?

Status
Not open for further replies.
Page may contain affiliate links. Please see terms for details.

MrGrumpy

Huge Member
Location
Fly Fifer
I used to work in haulage, including driving in Europe. Most HGV movements are prohibited on Sundays in France, the exceptions were for perishables (usually in fridge vans) heading to market or ferries. As you say, most drivers then use the weekends for their weekly rest period as required by drivers hours regulations, which require 3hrs continuous rest (no work). At weekends it is common to see lots of HGVs parked up at Service Areas, effectively the driver is stopped there for 24-36hrs.

In respect of weekends and particularly Sundays, France has a good setup, Supermarkets closed, businesses closed, no deliveries means people relax, socialise, exercise and generally switch off from work. People need time to recharge, just like EVs

Noticed Germany the same when I was there last year . I hark back to those days , everything is a rush these days !
 

oldwheels

Legendary Member
Location
Isle of Mull
Young old bloke's special situation is an outlier in requirements.

Generally EVs will cover 99% of the population's requirements to commute to work and travel to tourist destinations with a comfort/rest stop incorporating a top up charge.

Just to keep the pertinent statistic at the forefront- 95% of all car journeys are 35miles or less per day.

Just for the record I am in a similar position to youngoldbloke as my walking is restricted and I carry a recumbent trike as well as a folded mobility scooter.
I used to do up to 400 mile day drives in the past for business with some drop offs but mostly picking up goods with my main destination in the Scottish borders. These pickups served as breaks since there were price and quantity negotiations involved.
 

Alex321

Guru
Location
South Wales

icowden

Veteran
Location
Surrey
No longer even saving much if anything. They are going to have to be a lot better and cheaper before I would consider one.



https://www.parkers.co.uk/electric-cars/electric-charging-infrastructure-uk/

What @Alex321 says. It's a bit of a false premise. You don't solely fuel a card using expensive rapid chargers. You charge at home, or find parking with an 11kw charger. Using a rapid charger is really only an emergency top up, or a necessary surcharge on a long journey.

My current off peak rate (2am to 6am) is 9p per kwh. So over two nights I can pretty much "fill" my ID4 for about £7.50. That will take me 250 miles(ish). So whereas my old scenic used to cost £100+ to fill and do 500 miles, the ID4 costs me £15. If I need to fill off peak it would cost £33.20, so still £35 cheaper the the scenic. If I needed to to a complete fill at a rapid charger at 79p per Kwh then it would cost me £65, so yes, more expensive than diesel. But I would never do that. At best I'd be topping up say 40kwh - so about £30, to do an extra hundred miles or so in order to get to my destination where hopefully there is free or cheaper charging.

Of course on the Diesel comparison, we aren't actually comparing correctly as we need to compare with filling at a motorway services and not our local garage. So to fill the scenic at Fleet Services a £1.97 per litre would cost just under £120.
 
Most people will do most of their charging at home though, not using public rapid chargers.

So overall, most will still find it cheaper, even if having to recharge away from home works out more expensive.

I think it might be more true to replace that all-encompassing 'most people' with 'most people in some social demographics' ...
A great many people will find it impossible, or at the very least, achingly difficult, to charge at home.
 

FishFright

More wheels than sense
I think it might be more true to replace that all-encompassing 'most people' with 'most people in some social demographics' ...
A great many people will find it impossible, or at the very least, achingly difficult, to charge at home.

Best use up all that oil and watch the world burn safe in the knowledge that no one was asked to change a single thing .
 

icowden

Veteran
Location
Surrey
I think it might be more true to replace that all-encompassing 'most people' with 'most people in some social demographics' ...
A great many people will find it impossible, or at the very least, achingly difficult, to charge at home.
Why will they find it "achingly difficult"?
It's far easier than using a petrol pump and done in seconds. The cable is easy to connect and easy to disconnect.
 

youngoldbloke

The older I get, the faster I used to be ...
I foresee considerable social unrest mid century, if not before. I'll be long gone, but I fear for my grandchildren
Why will they find it "achingly difficult"?
It's far easier than using a petrol pump and done in seconds. The cable is easy to connect and easy to disconnect.

Haven't we been through this before? It might be easy but not if you live in a row of small terraced houses, draping cables across pavements will give rise to numerous problems, even if you could guarantee parking directly outside your property. Installation of road side chargers, one to each property is highly unlikely in the foreseeable future, as is under road charging.
 
Most people will do most of their charging at home though, not using public rapid chargers.

So overall, most will still find it cheaper, even if having to recharge away from home works out more expensive.

Most people among the cohort who do not live in flats or terraced houses or HMOs, and/or who are not reliant on their landlord's permission to install a charger.

I just wish EV drivers would just accept that their driving pattern and the things they are prepared to do to drive their cars does not appeal to everybody, and that ICE drivers would do the same.

This is not a battle just a changing situation that some are more ready to sign up to than others at the moment.

The infrastructure, battery capacity and cost issues will get better, but no one yet knows how fast that progress will be.

Edit: apologies to KnittyNorah for some duplication.
 
draping cables across pavements will give rise to numerous problems, even if you could guarantee parking directly outside your property. Installation of road side chargers, one to each property is highly unlikely in the foreseeable future, as is under road charging.

I think a cable and a cover across the pavement is far easier than civil unrest.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom