Hi Ryan.
Because when the clamp bolt was originally tightened the post was inserted too far it will have shrunk the frame
to a smaller diameter or/and pulled it out of round. The material will not have sprung open when the bolt was undone.
If the gap that was pulled together is wide enough you can hold a nut in the gap, then screw a bolt/set screw in the threaded side
till it goes through the nut and into the unthreaded side of the frame. Holding the head of the bolt/set screw with one spanner
undo the nut along the thread.This will open up the gap and enlarge the i.d. of the frame.
If the gap is too small for a nut then a metal wedge, maybe a large screwdriver blade, can be tapped into the gap to open
it up.
Which ever method is used to open up the frame the seat post will just lift out since the Plus Gas, WD40 has already been applied.
HTH
Paul G
(Engineerly)