Mass arrests 'Critical Mass' cycle ride during Olympics opening

Page may contain affiliate links. Please see terms for details.

dellzeqq

pre-talced and mighty
Location
SW2
[QUOTE 1957401, member: 45"]Why do you want to know how many commute in Birmingham?[/quote]
out of interest. Every time I've been to Birmingham I've been struck by how few cyclists I see - far fewer than Manchester or even Oxford.
 

Dan B

Disengaged member
It seems to me though, that there is a conflict of priorities - those of cyclists v the 'needs' of business & commerce. So far as road use goes (in a city), cyclists' needs are always going to be of fairly low priority.
Someone with fewer broken arms than me can start the debate on how and in which direction this apparent conflict is resolved. But I'm not even sure it necessarily exists: the implication seems to be that people on bikes are not people who work for businesses or are engaged in commerce. Are you really suggesting that all the cyclists I see on the city roads between 8 and 9am are actually out for pleasure rides?


Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using fewer fingers than I would really like
 

dellzeqq

pre-talced and mighty
Location
SW2
Criminy!

However in January 2010 a BBC investigation revealed that Buckfast had been mentioned in 5,638 crime reports in the Strathclyde area of Scotland from 2006–2009, equating to an average of three per day. One in 10 of those offences had been violent and 114 times in that period a Buckfast bottle was used as a weapon. A survey at a Scottish young offenders’ institution showed of the 117 people who drank alcohol before committing their crimes, 43 percent said they had drunk Buckfast. In another study of litter around a typical council estate in Scotland, 35 percent of the items identified as rubbish were Buckfast bottles
 

dellzeqq

pre-talced and mighty
Location
SW2
[QUOTE 1957413, member: 45"]Though it's picked up a fair bit over the past few years, it's never been great. It's the horrific road planning that's at fault, and that it's always been our motor city.[/quote]
Birmingham considered as a city (as opposed to a part of the West Midlands metroplex) is small, arranged radially, and ideal for bicycle journeys...........except, that, as you say, the highways planning, even in the centre of town, is inimical to cycling. Things may have changed, but I recall a lot of one way streets with smoothed corners.

Over and above that I wonder if there is a cultural basis for cycling. There are cities in which cycling is seen as progressive or normal or even (dare I say it) middle class. I don't see that in Birmingham (which is, by the way, my favourite city in the world apart from London)

Now,,,,just down the road is the Best Bike Club of All. What's happened in Stourbridge is that one person has made cycling desirable. That doesn't make Stourbridge a cycling town, but it has shifted the culture. My point is that sometimes it's not about committees or elections, but about people just getting out and making a difference.
 

PK99

Legendary Member
Location
SW19
actually I don't think it had a definite aim. It was, as far as I recall, as much about having a place to **** within walking distance of the city as it was a protest about aristos owning the countryside..

7

the clear and started objective was to claim a right of access to the countryside
 

PK99

Legendary Member
Location
SW19
sorry, but there are direct comparisons

the Kinder Scout trespassers were 400 in number. Some fell in to a fight with the gamekeepers, some were arrested and a couple were sent to prison. The rest is how you write history.

I'd accept indirect comparisons bit not direct: Kinderscout was about claiming right of access to areas where access was denied by law. Cyclists have more right of access to the road network than motorists
 

pubrunner

Legendary Member
Someone with fewer broken arms than me can start the debate on how and in which direction this apparent conflict is resolved.

Probably not me then - I've broken my left arm, three times . . . twice bike related.

Are you really suggesting that all the cyclists I see on the city roads between 8 and 9am are actually out for pleasure rides?

No, I'm not suggesting that at all !

The point that I'm trying to put across, is that the 'movers & shakers' in London, who keep the wheels of commerce & business turning, ain't too concerned with the 'rights' of cyclists. As priorities go, it is way down on their lists. (It isn't something with which I agree, btw)
 

dellzeqq

pre-talced and mighty
Location
SW2
I'd accept indirect comparisons bit not direct: Kinderscout was about claiming right of access to areas where access was denied by law. Cyclists have more right of access to the road network than motorists
1. there was violence
2. the numbers were similar
and the rest, as I said, is how you write history
 

dellzeqq

pre-talced and mighty
Location
SW2
the clear and started objective was to claim a right of access to the countryside
maybe so - but Richard Hoggart made the point this was about righting an historical wrong, and for others, stuck in overcrowded accommodation, it was about having a bit of privacy for sex. My point is that people protest for all kinds of reasons.
 
Top Bottom