Looking For New Wheel Set

Page may contain affiliate links. Please see terms for details.

chrisb1357

Über Member
Hi all,

Cut a long story short I have had my Giant Defy 4 since the start of the year and 4 months in the giant wheels failed so Giant replaced them for a set of Shimano RS 010 which have been ok but after a few rides I have noticed the rear wheel has a slight wobble on the rim which is how my first set started to fail so I am now looking for a decent wheel set but my budget is not massive and wanted some advice on what to look for or who to speak to.

The main issue is my weight which is around 115KG which has always been the same for years. I have now started to do three rides of around 25 miles a week and also started to enter some long distance rides and I am just worried about these factory built shimano wheels.

I have already been in touch with a local hand built wheel builder called 23mm near Derby and he has quoted the following spec of wheels but as I am new to all this I don't know if am getting a good deal or should I contact a few other wheel builders for prices and specs.

23mm have quoted the following.

For your weight, and to keep the cost down I would suggest the following build spec, all of which contains very robust components that would suit you:

Miche Primato Syntesi 36-spoke hubset
Ryde Sputnik 36-spoke rims
Sapim Race spokes and brass nipples

The hubs, rims and spokes are available in either black or silver. The black colour profile will cost you £228 delivered / silver £217.

I offer a 1 year warranty for the wheels, so if anything goes wrong with them in the first year of using them (not including a crash or pothole incident), you can send them to me for truing or re-building if necessary.
 

si_c

Guru
Location
Wirral
To be honest, I doubt you need new rims, get the bike to a local bike shop and ask them to re-true the wheels, this should cost no more than £20 or so, this will fix the problem with the wheel wobbling and hopefully prevent it re-occuring. Shimano wheels are generally pretty good, but they are not always perfectly setup out of the factory, a good local shop should be able to fix it reasonably quickly.

Hand-built wheels are fantastic, and a good set, particularly a 36 spoke set like you've looked at there are a good investment and will last a long time, but they're far more expensive than simply re-truing the wheel. To put things into perspective I run on a set of cheap wheels for a year weighing around what you do now with no problems other than the occasional re-true.
 

Ajax Bay

Guru
Location
East Devon
Your rear wheel takes much more of your weight (maybe 60/40 split) and the required dishing on the rear means the wheel is weaker, ceteris paribus. So, if you do go down this route but wish to keep the cost down, may be worth considering just getting a hand built rear (and the specs look entirely sensible and reasonable).
 
OP
OP
C

chrisb1357

Über Member
Thanks for the advice.

The guy that has quoted me on the wheel set has said he could true and check the current wheel over for £25 first before I spend the £200+ on a new set

Chris
 
The guy that has quoted me on the wheel set has said he could true and check the current wheel over for £25 first before I spend the £200+ on a new set

I'd go for the former as a short-term fix but save up for a hand-built set in the medium-to-long term. As @Ajax Bay says, the spec quoted above seems decent. @Spoked Wheels has given me good advice in the past and has built wheels for some on this forum. You could drop him a line if you wanted to enquire about other spec options. I'm saving up for some myself at the moment which he has agreed to build for me.

Cheers.
 

vickster

Squire
@Spoked Wheels built some good strong wheels for my steel tourer as the fulcrum 5s didn't like dealing with my weight and that of my luggage. 32 spokes on the front, 36 on the back. Mavic open pro rims, Novatec hubs, decent spokes. Sub £250
 

Nibor

Bewildered
Location
Accrington
I bought these https://www.rosebikes.co.uk/article...-mavic-open-pro--free-jack-shimano/aid:401802 they are also available on 105 for slightly less I like them a lot and weigh 135kg
 
OP
OP
C

chrisb1357

Über Member
Good to know about the Mavic Open Pro's and they are holding up for you. Was you having the same issues as me with cheaper rims not lasting.

Would there be much difference in the Xtreme Road wheel set 28"/700C Mavic Open Pro / Free Jack Shimanov v the hand built ones?

Also a dumb question but does it matter what hub you have on wheels v's what group set is on the bike. I have a Defy 4 2015 which has the Claris group set. Would putting the Xtreme Road wheel set 28"/700C Mavic Open Pro / Free Jack Shimano be any issues for me
 

Ajax Bay

Guru
Location
East Devon
does it matter what hub you have on wheels v's what group set is on the bike. I have a Defy 4 2015 which has the Claris group set. Would putting the Xtreme Road wheel set 28"/700C Mavic Open Pro / Free Jack Shimano be any issues for me
It'd be fine - it does matter but the wheelset you linked to is compatible with your shifter, derailleur and chain. The site confirms this too. Your OLN (aka hub width) is 130mm on the Defy and the Claris (standard) cassette will slide on the freehub. May need spacers but that's detail.
"hub width: 100 mm / 130 mm
· compatability: Shimano 7-/8-/9-/10-/11-speed"
 
Top Bottom