If your granny or father was in a care home, would you want someone who was 400% more likely (100/(100-81)) to develop symptomatic illness and even more liable if you add in asymptomatic illness (both states infectious to different degrees) to have multiple close contact with your relative? Edit: Put yourself in the role of Care Home lead: how would the risk assessment go? What risk mitigation measures might you include to reduce the risk to ALARP?
Not sure what Augmented Live Action Role Playing has to do with this, but the above is basically why I have mixed feelings about this: the freedom of carers to decide what risks they take with their own health versus the rights of those cared for to decide not to risk contact with them.
As for underlying medical condition that makes vaccination against COVID-19 potentially problematic: they deserve support if they have to change jobs, but it's not that unusual for people to be excluded from jobs due to medical conditions. Despite looking like a younger
@Drago and fighting off numerous unwanted advances with a bicycle pump, it's never been likely that I would pass the medical to be an astronaut, for example.
One step at a time. The merits of a 'group' being placed into the mandatory vaccination category will be subject to wide and detailed public scrutiny, as this one has.
We have next to naff all power to influence the decision, though. I hope the various reports are being made to parliament and MPs given a free vote on it.
The UK is a free country: [...]
but for other reasons off-topic here (I want my citizenship back). Really, the acid test will be whether MPs are given a free vote.
ETA: Prof Wilkinson, Medical Ethics, University of Oxford, said: "There is a strong ethical case that care home workers (and NHS staff) who have not had the COVID vaccine should be redeployed to areas other than frontline care."
Someone from a care home association was on TV news yesterday pointing out that most care homes do not have vast arrays of backline care staff, with many services often contracted in, so redeployment opportunities are few. If they have more than a few frontline carers banned from the frontline, the choice will be firing them and/or closing down. I really hope an impact assessment is made before the decision is taken.