Windows file transfer problem to large USB data sticks - any ideas?
- Thread starter beanzontoast
- Start date
Page may contain affiliate links. Please see terms for details.
OP
OP
beanzontoast
Guru
- Location
- South of The Peaks
Don’t think so - they don't feel hot to the touch.
lazybloke
Priest of the cult of Chris Rea
- Location
- Leafy Surrey
Just recreated @presta's experiment using a close to 3 Gbyte file to three USB storage devices:
Sandisk USB stick - not their 'extreme' range, but I thought it was USB 3. Disappointing speed.
Inconsistent speed too, although a strangely regular pattern. It also failed at 99%. Several times (apparently the device "does not exist").
USB connected HDD. Faster than the sandisk stick, and much more consistent.
And with a newer USB stick; fastest of all, but why the hell did it slow down between 55% and 65% ? Maybe there was a power-saving setting; I should have wiggled a mouse.
After careful consideration of the entire thread, and with my cumulative knowledge and experience of using computers for over 40 years, I conclude that USB sticks are weird.
Sandisk USB stick - not their 'extreme' range, but I thought it was USB 3. Disappointing speed.
Inconsistent speed too, although a strangely regular pattern. It also failed at 99%. Several times (apparently the device "does not exist").
USB connected HDD. Faster than the sandisk stick, and much more consistent.
And with a newer USB stick; fastest of all, but why the hell did it slow down between 55% and 65% ? Maybe there was a power-saving setting; I should have wiggled a mouse.
After careful consideration of the entire thread, and with my cumulative knowledge and experience of using computers for over 40 years, I conclude that USB sticks are weird.
ColinJ
Puzzle game procrastinator!
- Location
- Todmorden - Yorks/Lancs border
I copied 3 x 0.5 GB files to my 16 GB USB 3 Kingston DataTraveler G4. There was a ramping up of speed at the start, then one brief dip, before it settled into a steady 16 MB/s transfer. Total time taken was 1 min 43 seconds. The stick got warm but not hot.
OP
OP
beanzontoast
Guru
- Location
- South of The Peaks
Just to update - I booted into Mint and tried the experiment there. The same stuttering stop-start data transfer.
Enough, you darn sticks!
I dug out my spare 2.5” caddy, fixed a 240gb SSD in it and moved the files between laptop and base unit without any fuss at all. Nice, steady data rate. For good measure, while it was connected to the laptop, I ran a backup as well.
Enough, you darn sticks!
I dug out my spare 2.5” caddy, fixed a 240gb SSD in it and moved the files between laptop and base unit without any fuss at all. Nice, steady data rate. For good measure, while it was connected to the laptop, I ran a backup as well.
DCBassman
Guru
- Location
- The lumpy far South West
Glad that's sorted! I use Sandisk sticks, because the provided encryption has been useful GDPR/business-wise. Have also used Samsung and Kioxia (aka Toshiba) for sticks and SD cards.
Ming the Merciless
There is no mercy
- Location
- Inside my skull
The USB drive probably has a high-speed cache (50+ MB/s writing). When this small cache is full, the drive writes to slower flash memory.
