Well well well... I tried the Trek and a Genesis Equilibrium 20.
Trek was very tempting on looks alonr. When i first saw it i thought WOW much better the rubbish pics on website. This is it i thought.
But then on test rides... Yes 'rides'.,, i went out FIVE times on them.., i was sooo stretched to reach handlebars on Trek... Why?? Only a 56 frame. My Higher Back/ shoulders moaning straight away. Couldn't believe it. Guys at
Evans lowered saddle, moved it fwd a bit, even flipped stem so it pointed upwards. That all helped, and i was soooo trying to convince myself that it was 'ok'... But it just felt wrong. And w higher handlebars it was like a 'hybrid'. Not good.
After 100yds on the Genesis it felt like WOW WHAT IS THIS?? fitted like a glove. Zero discomfort. Hands moulded on brake hoods. No back pain. Ok, not the best looker, but every time i tried the tweaked Trek, the Genesis erased the memory. I had to accept at the end the genesis was immensely superior. Soo smooth, 105 mech spot on (saw no difference between my current Claris and Trek's Tiagra, just like bag of spanners). In the end it was clear i could happily keep riding the genesis all day.
I even asked for other bikes to see I didn't suffer an anti-Tre effect. A Speesh Tarmac on 56 and Fuji on 54 frames. Nice looking, big round tubing, oversized bot braket etc, but not the same feel. Tarmac was like the Wilier, nice and fast, but i know my shoulders wouldn't last long.
Instead there is some magic from the steel frame, it is just spot on. The test route went over bad tarmac and it just glide through. Very happy now. Best thing was Evans honoured the trade in agreement (which expired last Mon), so knocked off £100 of genesis price by giving them my son's little bike, AND allowed me to use c2w