I think that
@Sea of vapours will be interested in today's fettling...
I went on a hilly North/West Yorkshire ride with him at the start of August. I was on my best bike, a 20 year old Cannondale CAAD 5. It is still a great bike, but it started making some annoying noises on the ride which I was determined to eliminate after recovering from the ride.
I did some fettling in the weeks that followed. I replaced the chain, cassette, bottom bracket, and chainrings. None of them turned out to be worn so badly that they had actually
needed replacing at the time but I had bought the spares so I thought I might as well put them on. It's nice to have new bits on the bike. The semi-used parts are now in my spares box. It is nice to have semi-used bits in the spares box - you never know when they might come in handy...
I did manage to find a noisy component... one of my SPD pedals was clicking. New pedals time! The old pedals have gone in the spares box to be fettled at a later date. The new pedals eliminated some of the noises that I had been hearing.
BUT... there was still a clicky, ticky noise every now and then. It seemed to come and go. I couldn't quite figure it out. Then a pal noticed that there was a little play in the freehub!
I whipped the freehub off. EUREKA!
Take a look at its outer sealed bearing... Or should that be an UNsealed bearing!!!!
With apologies to the Monty Python team...
This bearing is no more! It has ceased to be! It's expired and gone to meet its maker! It's a stiff! Bereft of life, it rests in peace! ... It's kicked the bucket, it's shuffled off its mortal coil, run down the curtain and joined the bleedin' choir invisible!! THIS IS AN EX-BEARING!!
A wise man once said...
It is also nice to have semi-used bits in the spares box - you never know when they might come in handy...
Well, I remembered that I had a semi-used freehub in my spares box! This is what the other sealed bearing should have looked like in situ...
I have stopped mid-fettle to have something to eat but I am pretty confident that the fettling will be completed later, and that a test ride tomorrow will confirm that the problem has been fixed. I will report back after that!
PS
One of the things that confused me was that the noise kept coming and going. WHY?!
I think now that when I was using a high gear (the chain on the small sprockets) my pedalling forces were acting mainly on the smashed outer freehub bearing, which naturally did not sound good. In fact, I think it is amazing that it did not sound even worse!
When in a low gear (the chain on the big, inner sprockets) my pedalling forces were acting mainly on the intact inner freehub bearing, which coped with the load and left me in peace.