I have put 2 new chainrings on my CAAD5. I had already put a new chain and cassette on and thought I might get away with keeping the old rings, but the new chain was making a lot of noise and I think it was because of wear on the small and middle rings. Once I compared the old rings with the replacements, it was fairly obvious that the old teeth were significantly worn.
The old rings were made of 'Dural' which is a softish grade of aluminium and they only lasted me one season. I've spent more this time and got 'Zicral' rings which are supposed to last much longer. I'll eventually see if the extra life justifies the extra cost.
The big ring looked ok so I didn't change that.
Now for a test ride ...
[Time passes ...]
I am back from a 21 mile test ride ...
Verdict ...? That's better! The gears are working nicely now. The shifting is better, and the transmission feels more 'direct' without the sloppiness of the old worn parts. The bike is MUCH quieter - various noises had been annoying me and they have almost disappeared now. The elusive ticking sound has pretty much been eliminated. The old big ring does seem to be working fine. I don't use the big ring as much as the middle ring and when it is used, the load is spread over more teeth so it wears less.
The other thing I forgot to mention above is that I bought a 36 tooth middle ring to replace the old worn 38. It is a subtle change but it makes sense for my riding. The big ring is only a 48 and the smallest sprocket is only a 13 which means that I can use the big ring much more than I could on other bikes that I have owned. That means there is not the need to have a biggish middle ring. By using a smaller middle ring, I now have 3 sensible ranges of gears which don't overlap too much if cross-chained combinations are discounted. The big ring is good for 15+ mph = flat, undulating or downhill roads. The middle ring is ideal for about 10-17 mph = undulating roads and moderate climbs. The little ring is good for steep climbs and moderate ones climbed at up to about 12 mph.
I found that the steps between the rings now are such that I wasn't having to do a double shift when changing between them, I felt happy enough staying on the same sprocket for at least a few pedal revs. I didn't get that feeling of having to spin like mad, or my legs seizing up when I changed rings without a corresponding shift at the back.
Oh, and one last quick fettle was done by a mate who is better with a spoke key than me. I noticed a bit of a wobble in the rear wheel. He reduced that by about 75% but didn't want to go any further because the spoke tensions were diverging too much. Ideally, he would like to spend more time on the wheel and do it properly but I told him not to bother. I think it will be ok.