The CycleChat Helmet Debate Thread

Page may contain affiliate links. Please see terms for details.

PaulSB

Squire
My current knowledge of helmets is not extensive and this is subject I shall soon discuss with the LBS I have used for 20+ years.. My brief history is this; very experienced club cyclist, generally averaging 16mph, 80-85 miles, 5-6000 feet climbing three times a week. At 64 I've had three experiences which convince me a helmet is a positive contribution to my personal safety.

Three weeks ago the third experience convinced me I need to revisit the subject. On February 1st I suffered a subarachnoid haemorrage. It seems I will make a 100% recovery. I am after advice re helmet designs and type which will aid my protection. I am very open to discussion as to why one brand would be better than another - I am not open to discussion on the wisdom or otherwise of wearing a helmet.

Many thanks
 

mjr

Comfy armchair to one person & a plank to the next
Three weeks ago the third experience convinced me I need to revisit the subject. On February 1st I suffered a subarachnoid haemorrage. It seems I will make a 100% recovery. I am after advice re helmet designs and type which will aid my protection. I am very open to discussion as to why one brand would be better than another - I am not open to discussion on the wisdom or otherwise of wearing a helmet.
You just suffered a head injury despite being a helmet user and still aren't open to discussion - are you sure this is the right place to post? But anyway, the general advice for die-hard helmet users to prefer ones meeting the tougher Snell tests (there was a list of current passes on www.smf.org last I checked) rather than the watered-down EN tests is probably still relevant. Beyond that, it's probably better to ask your medical specialist caring for your injury for advice.
 

classic33

Leg End Member
You just suffered a head injury despite being a helmet user and still aren't open to discussion - are you sure this is the right place to post? But anyway, the general advice for die-hard helmet users to prefer ones meeting the tougher Snell tests (there was a list of current passes on www.smf.org last I checked) rather than the watered-down EN tests is probably still relevant. Beyond that, it's probably better to ask your medical specialist caring for your injury for advice.
I've approached this subject on the basis of frequent, non cycling related, head impact. Repeated blunt trauma impact over 50+ years.

No risk compemsation involved, unless you count getting by as best as I can, whilst not wearing a helmet.
 

glasgowcyclist

Charming but somewhat feckless
Location
Scotland
I am after advice re helmet designs and type which will aid my protection.

I can't advise on suitability but I do hope you find one that meets your needs.

It would be interesting to hear individual manufacturers' responses as to which helmet (if any) in their range was most apt for your circumstances.
If you do get a useful reply it could be helpful to others to read it here since it may help them to reach a decision on their own best option.
 

classic33

Leg End Member
My current knowledge of helmets is not extensive and this is subject I shall soon discuss with the LBS I have used for 20+ years.. My brief history is this; very experienced club cyclist, generally averaging 16mph, 80-85 miles, 5-6000 feet climbing three times a week. At 64 I've had three experiences which convince me a helmet is a positive contribution to my personal safety.

Three weeks ago the third experience convinced me I need to revisit the subject. On February 1st I suffered a subarachnoid haemorrage. It seems I will make a 100% recovery. I am after advice re helmet designs and type which will aid my protection. I am very open to discussion as to why one brand would be better than another - I am not open to discussion on the wisdom or otherwise of wearing a helmet.

Many thanks
Consider the area(s) impacted and the site of the latest reason.

Consider trying to trial one of the inflatable helmets. You may have to go through your Dr. or specialist though. I'd try the specialist first, then the Dr.

Mention it when you go to your LBS, get another opinion on it.
 

Pat "5mph"

A kilogrammicaly challenged woman
Moderator
Location
Glasgow
Rant alert!
Today a cyclist felt the need to tell me, from the shared path he was on (I was on the adjacent road) "you should wear a helmet".
Now, I know many cyclists in Glasgow, there's not that many compared to, say, London, so I ask him "do I know you?"
He answers "no, but you should wear a helmet"
Taps his helmet "I had two accidents", then proceeds round the blind corner full of pedestrians (that's why I was on the road, not on the shared path), then carries on to ride on a clearly signed bus only lane.
Well, blow me off my bike, the impertinent git!
Rant over ^_^
 

mjr

Comfy armchair to one person & a plank to the next
Rant alert!
Today a cyclist felt the need to tell me, from the shared path he was on (I was on the adjacent road) "you should wear a helmet".
Now, I know many cyclists in Glasgow, there's not that many compared to, say, London, so I ask him "do I know you?"
He answers "no, but you should wear a helmet"
Taps his helmet "I had two accidents", then proceeds round the blind corner full of pedestrians (that's why I was on the road, not on the shared path), then carries on to ride on a clearly signed bus only lane.
Well, blow me off my bike, the impertinent git!
Rant over ^_^
It was the hottest day of the year so far and there is a hypothesis that wrapping one's brain in insulating foam warms it up to the point of impairing one's judgment and that's what negated the tested protective effect in population statistics that show injury trends continuing unaffected by changes in helmet usage rates...
 

Slick

Guru
Rant alert!
Today a cyclist felt the need to tell me, from the shared path he was on (I was on the adjacent road) "you should wear a helmet".
Now, I know many cyclists in Glasgow, there's not that many compared to, say, London, so I ask him "do I know you?"
He answers "no, but you should wear a helmet"
Taps his helmet "I had two accidents", then proceeds round the blind corner full of pedestrians (that's why I was on the road, not on the shared path), then carries on to ride on a clearly signed bus only lane.
Well, blow me off my bike, the impertinent git!
Rant over ^_^
It's unlike you to react to bad advice from someone less knowledgeable than your good self @Pat "5mph" . :laugh:

On a slightly more sombre note, I had a warning from a guy who reckoned his whole life had been affected by a knock on the head as a young man and he was very concerned that I should always where a helmet.

I took his advice with a smile and a bit of a chat as I understood why he might think that.
 

ozboz

Guru
Location
Richmond ,Surrey
My current knowledge of helmets is not extensive and this is subject I shall soon discuss with the LBS I have used for 20+ years.. My brief history is this; very experienced club cyclist, generally averaging 16mph, 80-85 miles, 5-6000 feet climbing three times a week. At 64 I've had three experiences which convince me a helmet is a positive contribution to my personal safety.

Three weeks ago the third experience convinced me I need to revisit the subject. On February 1st I suffered a subarachnoid haemorrage. It seems I will make a 100% recovery. I am after advice re helmet designs and type which will aid my protection. I am very open to discussion as to why one brand would be better than another - I am not open to discussion on the wisdom or otherwise of wearing a helmet.

Many thanks

Your post is a couple of months old so yoay have already seen this new Trek helmet technology
If no this is worth a read

https://www.popsci.com/trek-wavecel-bicycle-helmet-science
 

Steve T

Veteran
I was knocked off my bike last week and I was wearing a helmet. Today I happened to walk past the car that hit me as it was literally 2 minutes from my house. Attached are pictures of the dent my head (inside the helmet )made to the car bodywork. Whether you wear a helmet is your own choice but I'm certainly glad I did.
IMG_5823.jpg
 

Attachments

  • IMG_5822.jpg
    IMG_5822.jpg
    124.1 KB · Views: 13

Ming the Merciless

There is no mercy
Location
Inside my skull
Rant alert!
Today a cyclist felt the need to tell me, from the shared path he was on (I was on the adjacent road) "you should wear a helmet".
Now, I know many cyclists in Glasgow, there's not that many compared to, say, London, so I ask him "do I know you?"
He answers "no, but you should wear a helmet"
Taps his helmet "I had two accidents", then proceeds round the blind corner full of pedestrians (that's why I was on the road, not on the shared path), then carries on to ride on a clearly signed bus only lane.
Well, blow me off my bike, the impertinent git!
Rant over ^_^

Accident prone ediot tells you to wear a helmet. Oh the irony.
 

mjr

Comfy armchair to one person & a plank to the next
I was knocked off my bike last week and I was wearing a helmet. Today I happened to walk past the car that hit me as it was literally 2 minutes from my house. Attached are pictures of the dent my head (inside the helmet )made to the car bodywork. Whether you wear a helmet is your own choice but I'm certainly glad I did. View attachment 464931
Most cycle helmets are not designed or tested for colliding with other vehicles. Is yours different or was any protection probably a fluke?
 
Top Bottom