I would check with your LBS as to whether or not you can use C2W for a new groupset and wheels for your current bike. If the frame is in good nic and you love it, then this could be a great option. You might still be able to get your hands on 11 speed 105 and a nice set of hand built wheels for much less than £2k
New bike time - don’t know where to start!
- Thread starter Julia9054
- Start date
Page may contain affiliate links. Please see terms for details.
I would check with your LBS as to whether or not you can use C2W for a new groupset and wheels for your current bike. If the frame is in good nic and you love it, then this could be a great option. You might still be able to get your hands on 11 speed 105 and a nice set of hand built wheels for much less than £2k
Alex321
Guru
- Location
- South Wales
The C2W scheme the OP is able to use is the Halfords cycle2work one, which only operates with a limited selection of independent retailers (plus of course Halfords and Tredz).
And they have also said their LBS has recently closed.
Looking at the cycle2work site, and based on the stated location of Knaresborough, there are three LBS in Harrogate and one in Ripon that they could use, though only one of those looks like having bikes in their price range.
Last edited:
Note the exact size and the position of points of contact to ensure that you can replicate your position on any new bike.
All uphill
Still rolling along
- Location
- Somerset
Spa (in Yorkshire) did me a 46/30 crankset with a 40/11 cassette . Gets me up most things!
Last edited:
OP
OP
Julia9054
Guru
- Location
- Knaresborough
Update - I have decided that dipping into my savings and getting mine refurbished is the way to go.
I dropped into Spa Cycles yesterday who told me they only work on their own bikes. I asked to speak to their mechanic, explained what i wanted and asked if he could recommend anyone. He called a bloke called Josh from out back who works there 2 days a week and does his own projects the rest of the time. We discussed some possibilities and I'm taking it over to him in North Leeds for him to have a look at on Sunday.
I dropped into Spa Cycles yesterday who told me they only work on their own bikes. I asked to speak to their mechanic, explained what i wanted and asked if he could recommend anyone. He called a bloke called Josh from out back who works there 2 days a week and does his own projects the rest of the time. We discussed some possibilities and I'm taking it over to him in North Leeds for him to have a look at on Sunday.
IanSmithCSE
Guru
- Location
- Worcester, Worcestershire
Good afternoon,
I fully "grok" the refurb route but....... I couldn't work out which Jamis you had and a post search didn't help, but it did turn up one where you were considering a touring bike to fit between the Jamis and the Specialized Diverge.
This suggests that you have quite clear requirements for your equipment and as any CF framed bike sold around 2012-2014 would generally be quite highly spec'd I wonder if you will be disappointed by doing a refurb.
Apart from possibly going from 10 to 12 speed, as far as I am aware there have been no big changes in mechanical group sets. So you would be spending your money on getting back to where you were, I am very comfortable with 10 speed and expect to be forced to 12 in the near future (Di2) but I have no desire for 12 speed.
The exception would be if the Jamis has disc brakes, this would open up the option of 105 Di2, the price is horrendous, typically around the £1,400 mark plus the cost having it fitted and the cost of making Di2 work with a cable based frame. So it may be cheaper to buy a new 105 Di2 bike.
But I absolutely adore Di2, for me it is a much bigger improvement than going from a 531 to CF frame and as controversial point I suspect that many people don't like admitting that they can't afford it so they rubbish it.
As I commute a bit under 40 miles a day I decided that I would use my best bike, a CF Jamis with Di2 and recently bought a new steel frame and built up a "retro" bike. The retro bike is way worse than the Jamis in every way, but I really enjoy riding it because I approach the ride knowing that this is as things once were.
I have spent around £1,200 on the Raleigh, it has new frame, wheels, shifters, saddle, seat pin, bb, bars and stem and from my spare parts bin front and rear mechs, brake levers and chainset. I would like to replace the drive train when I find the right bits and expect to end up at around £1,500.
So my question is would a complete change of direction and a step back in absolute performance actually give you more fun?
Bye
Ian
I fully "grok" the refurb route but....... I couldn't work out which Jamis you had and a post search didn't help, but it did turn up one where you were considering a touring bike to fit between the Jamis and the Specialized Diverge.
This suggests that you have quite clear requirements for your equipment and as any CF framed bike sold around 2012-2014 would generally be quite highly spec'd I wonder if you will be disappointed by doing a refurb.
Apart from possibly going from 10 to 12 speed, as far as I am aware there have been no big changes in mechanical group sets. So you would be spending your money on getting back to where you were, I am very comfortable with 10 speed and expect to be forced to 12 in the near future (Di2) but I have no desire for 12 speed.
The exception would be if the Jamis has disc brakes, this would open up the option of 105 Di2, the price is horrendous, typically around the £1,400 mark plus the cost having it fitted and the cost of making Di2 work with a cable based frame. So it may be cheaper to buy a new 105 Di2 bike.
But I absolutely adore Di2, for me it is a much bigger improvement than going from a 531 to CF frame and as controversial point I suspect that many people don't like admitting that they can't afford it so they rubbish it.
As I commute a bit under 40 miles a day I decided that I would use my best bike, a CF Jamis with Di2 and recently bought a new steel frame and built up a "retro" bike. The retro bike is way worse than the Jamis in every way, but I really enjoy riding it because I approach the ride knowing that this is as things once were.
I have spent around £1,200 on the Raleigh, it has new frame, wheels, shifters, saddle, seat pin, bb, bars and stem and from my spare parts bin front and rear mechs, brake levers and chainset. I would like to replace the drive train when I find the right bits and expect to end up at around £1,500.
So my question is would a complete change of direction and a step back in absolute performance actually give you more fun?
Bye
Ian
Last edited:
OP
OP
Julia9054
Guru
- Location
- Knaresborough
http://www.bikeroar.com/products/jamis/xenith-endura-sport-femme-2012/44-ocean-mist-natural-carbon
This is my bike.
http://www.bikeroar.com/products/jamis/xenith-endura-sport-femme-2012/specs
Specifications here.
It was £1500 reduced to £1000 and then bought on cycle to work so actually cost me about £750 from Evans in York
As far as I can see, the same entryish level cf bike now would set me back north of £2000. Added to that cost, C2W works with a more limited range of retailers than cyclescheme plus availability of bikes in my size (in a world where average size human still tends to mean average size man)
New bikes tend to come with the advantage of internal cable routing and disc brakes neither of which feel like a "must have"
We'll see what this mechanic says tomorrow. I really do appreciate reading everyone's advice on here - thank you.
This is my bike.
http://www.bikeroar.com/products/jamis/xenith-endura-sport-femme-2012/specs
Specifications here.
It was £1500 reduced to £1000 and then bought on cycle to work so actually cost me about £750 from Evans in York
As far as I can see, the same entryish level cf bike now would set me back north of £2000. Added to that cost, C2W works with a more limited range of retailers than cyclescheme plus availability of bikes in my size (in a world where average size human still tends to mean average size man)
New bikes tend to come with the advantage of internal cable routing and disc brakes neither of which feel like a "must have"
We'll see what this mechanic says tomorrow. I really do appreciate reading everyone's advice on here - thank you.
cyberknight
As long as I breathe, I attack.
- Location
- Land of confusion
keep 10 speed go 4700 tiagra , its dang good for the money if you are looking to do it on a "budget" , you will not gain much of anything going 11 or 12 speed . EDIT
Unless of course you get a really good deal on it but check your wheel choice supports it
Change the crankset to HT 2 and compatible BB, i always found fsa powerdrive BB`s to wear out pretty quickly.
Wheels assuming you have the originals how are they running and whats the brake surface like ? maybe look at a new set even an " entry " level set like shimano wh rs 100 are laible to be better ( they look like a replacement for rs 11s which im still using )
https://www.spacycles.co.uk/m10b0s205p4277/SHIMANO-WH-RS100-Front-and-Rear
or askiums ?
https://www.merlincycles.com/mavic-aksium-one-clincher-road-wheelset-75460.html
Unless of course you get a really good deal on it but check your wheel choice supports it
Change the crankset to HT 2 and compatible BB, i always found fsa powerdrive BB`s to wear out pretty quickly.
Wheels assuming you have the originals how are they running and whats the brake surface like ? maybe look at a new set even an " entry " level set like shimano wh rs 100 are laible to be better ( they look like a replacement for rs 11s which im still using )
https://www.spacycles.co.uk/m10b0s205p4277/SHIMANO-WH-RS100-Front-and-Rear
or askiums ?
https://www.merlincycles.com/mavic-aksium-one-clincher-road-wheelset-75460.html
Last edited:
cyberknight
As long as I breathe, I attack.
- Location
- Land of confusion
Or stick to what you know with a 10 speed 105 triple from Spa
i only say 4700 tiagra as i read that the shifting is a lot better than the old 10 speed 105
I love your use of initiative. Fingers crossed Josh can sort your bike out for you.
OP
OP
Julia9054
Guru
- Location
- Knaresborough
So do I. Feels slightly like letting a teenager you've never met babysit your kid! 😂
I've got that feeling round someone half my age who is going to help me with some back trouble! He doesn't look old enough to have left school....
Jameshow
Veteran
Depends on which 10 spd 105 perhaps under bar 105 (5700) but the earlier washing line 105 (5600?) is perhaps a tad lighter than 4700.
I have both on my summer bikes and it's fine for my needs.
