Helmets

Status
Not open for further replies.
Page may contain affiliate links. Please see terms for details.

I like Skol

A Minging Manc...
My OH is quite keen that I get one and I must admit I'd want my son to wear one, so I suppose it's hypocritical of me to feel reluctant to do so myself.


Not really, as Children's skulls are not fully developed and knitted, and also experience the low impact and speed accidents that cycle helmets are designed for.


I have resolutely refused to comment on any of these should I/shouldn't I helmet debates before but for some reason seem drawn into this one for the above points.

As a 37 yr old I have had every opportunity to wear a helmet if I wanted, I didn't really grow up in the time before helmets although it was still considered a bit of a cycle fanatic thing to wear one. I did have a brief flirtation with helmet wearing at the start of the 90's when I was in the MTB club at Uni and did a few races that required mandatory helmet wearing but apart from that I do not own or wear a cycle helmet for any cycling either MTB'ing or commuting. I don't judge others for wearing/not wearing a helmet and don't expect to be judged myself, it's up to the individual to choose what they feel safe with.

Now I have 2 sons, currently aged 8 and 5, and they have been made to wear a helmet everytime they have sat on a bike. I do feel slightly hypocritical for this but until they develop adequate balance, coordination and bike control that is the rule. 8 yr old is just reaching the stage where I am almost prepared to let him ride without a helmet as he doesn't really fall off any more. 5 yr old is still likely to fall or career into something (parked cars, trees, etc) so has to keep the helmet. Mrs Skol is incredibly more protective of our kids than I am so it is a constant battle between us and we both have to compomise to make sure we keep the kids safe without stifling their development and risk awareness (this isn't just on the helmet issue!).

8 yr old is starting to ride on the roads a little while accompanied by me and I suppose that once I am happy to let him loose on the roads solo I will also be happy for him to do it with or without a helmet. If he is aware of the road environment then he is as safe as can be regardless of helmet. If we do any MTB'ing that involves fast or technical down hilling, again I will insist on a helmet until he has demonstrated he can manage the terrain competently, after that it will be his choice.

I think that is the main point about cycle helmet wearing, the words that keep cropping up in any helmet debate, choose and choice. It should not be mandatory and no one has the right to say helmets should be worn and it is stupid not to. They are not the answer to all cycle injuries and should not be portrayed as such. Certainly they can prevent certain injuries but life is full of risks and some have to be accepted, attempting to prevent all risk would lead to a dull and futile existance.
 

Deb13b

New Member
Location
Co. Durham
Well I went and got one. And I look like a gimp 
 

Jezston

Über Member
Location
London
Now I have 2 sons, currently aged 8 and 5, and they have been made to wear a helmet everytime they have sat on a bike. I do feel slightly hypocritical for this but until they develop adequate balance, coordination and bike control that is the rule. 8 yr old is just reaching the stage where I am almost prepared to let him ride without a helmet as he doesn't really fall off any more. 5 yr old is still likely to fall or career into something (parked cars, trees, etc) so has to keep the helmet. Mrs Skol is incredibly more protective of our kids than I am so it is a constant battle between us and we both have to compomise to make sure we keep the kids safe without stifling their development and risk awareness (this isn't just on the helmet issue!).

Which is exactly what helmets were designed to protect against. No more. Seems sensible.

I wear a helmet on my commute because they might help and I FEEL a little safer and comfortable with it on, and I have had a couple of minor falls due to ice and/or stupidity and wearing the helmet has made them less painful. There doesn't appear to be any real hard evidence (further passes, rotational injuries etc) against wearing one so why not.

When I'm tootling about town doing my shopping I don't wear one, which is equally absurd as I'm probably far more likely to be in a collision when I'm doing that than when on my commute!
 

ramses

Active Member
Location
Bournemouth
This is a similarly tragic case, is there any reason why I should not simply use this to justify drinking helmets?

Using emotive blackmail to bully cyclists and scare them is silly when anyone who has looked at the evidence will know that only a small proportion of cases are cyclists.

Surely if the case you give is used as justification for cycle helmets you must support drinking helmets or explain why this assault victim's head injuries are not worth preventing... is it somehow easier to feed through a straw if the head injury is a non cycling one?



Why so angry
angry.gif


I didn't state that anyone should wear a helmet, I did state it was a personal choice.

I merely stated that I wear one, and that a lot of people I know say they don't, because they don't go fast enough. I just pointed out that it was not all about speed.

If you want to be that pedantic about it then yes we should all wear a helmet at all times. But that is just plain stupid.

The choice is yours and yours alone, life is a risk from day one, so it is down to the individual to decide which of those risks they will leave to chance and which ones to try and negate.

Glad you're happy not wearing one.

I am happy wearing mine.
biggrin.gif
biggrin.gif
biggrin.gif
biggrin.gif
biggrin.gif
biggrin.gif
biggrin.gif
 

Attachments

  • biggrin.gif
    biggrin.gif
    514 bytes · Views: 41
  • biggrin.gif
    biggrin.gif
    514 bytes · Views: 53
  • biggrin.gif
    biggrin.gif
    514 bytes · Views: 35
  • biggrin.gif
    biggrin.gif
    514 bytes · Views: 41
  • biggrin.gif
    biggrin.gif
    514 bytes · Views: 44
  • biggrin.gif
    biggrin.gif
    514 bytes · Views: 40

tuggy

Well-Known Member
Location
essex
I grew up on bikes in the days before helmets. I have owned a helmet in the past, but always felt a bit uncomfortable in it, through self-consciousness as much as anything.

Do you wear one? Does it make that much of a difference? Why don't you wear one?

Just nosy really!
icon_smile_tongue.gif
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom