Jimmy Doug
If you know what's good for you ...
My Sealskinz lobster mits are by far the best I've used, so far all the negative reviews I've seen of Sealskinz have been for the normal fingered gloves, although I suspect there's probably some for every kind. I went out this evening for what turned out to be a slow ride due to the amount of ice on the cyclepaths, it was meant to be -2 and I spent 10minutes repackaging my toolkit etc with bare hands, so put them onto cold fingers and was lovely and warm by the end of the ride, despite the terrible circulation I get in my fingers.
I think the size you buy gloves in is very important too and could possibly account for some poor reviews, like they need to have enough space to trap warm air around your fingers.
I think that the general consensus is that they're excellent gloves. I was going to get some myself but went for the BBBs in the end.