dellzeqq said:Those of you with a tablet of stone to hand, inscribe this now! Anything that isn't required to get a bike from A to B is going to be crap. The designers of this particular (British touring) bike had come up with a wizard wheeze. Why not fasten the mudguard to the forks with a bolt going upward in to the forks from the underside of the mudguard?
Actually, it's not a bad method if done right. I've used it on several bikes, and it's often better than the rather naff bit of bent metal sometimes provided on the rear mudguard, that you have to bend to shape and fit.
It seems likely that the problem in this case was that there appeared to be a heap of washers to get the spacing right, which made the whole lot more prone to rattling loose. Using some grease on the thread to get the bolt nice and tight, and possibly a serrated washer would probably have solved that.
The main problem was the axle fitted by brute force and ignorance, why they hadn't just opened the fork end out slightly with a file, or fitted a narrower axle is beyond me.