Cat or a Dog person?

Page may contain affiliate links. Please see terms for details.

Night Train

Maker of Things
marinyork said:
A cat is still certainly commitment and sadly I think too many people forget that, unfortunately people do with other pets too :tongue:. Cats still need their litter trays cleaning, any furballs or sick sorting out. Feeding. Fleas and checking regularly for other parasites or diseases, injections. Grooming. Most of them like human company regularly. Some people don't like their cats being out at night (they worry for their health or being stolen) and it can be a fair bit of effort looking for them. All right so it's not the same as dogs but some dogs are not the same as other dogs and cats vary a lot.
I much prefer animals to people. I have found that animals tend to be honest about how they feel about others and don't lie about things. When my dog has stolen the cake from the kitchen she has the decency to own up and look suitable guity, more then I can say for most kids I have known. Animals are also up front about whether or not they like you and have no hesitation in letting you know. They also love unconditionally and remain loyal and faithful.
 
OP
OP
R

Renard

Guest
Night Train said:
I can see what you mean there, I hadn't thought of it in that way. Maybe that explains why my ex wife has my dog and I have our cats.

I do have shared experiences with my cats, just different ones. One of my cats used to 'mother' me. She would call me to my bed at bed time and then make sure I was tucked in by walking up and down each side of me on the duvet before setting herself down to sleep beside me. She would then wash my face and ears in the morning to wake me up. It was cute for a while but then it got in the way of having a relationship as she was also jealous of me sharing a bed with another woman.
One of my other cats enjoys conversing with me with a series of sounds and body language. We seem to understand each other quite well.

Interesting, obviously I don't have a cat and TBH I do like one whenever I meet one and interact with it. Not totally different from my dog in its night time routine.
 

Speicher

Vice Admiral
Moderator
marinyork said:
A cat is still certainly commitment and sadly I think too many people forget that, unfortunately people do with other pets too :wacko:. Cats still need their litter trays cleaning, any furballs or sick sorting out. Feeding. Fleas and checking regularly for other parasites or diseases, injections. Grooming. Most of them like human company regularly. Some people don't like their cats being out at night (they worry for their health or being stolen) and it can be a fair bit of effort looking for them. All right so it's not the same as dogs but some dogs are not the same as other dogs and cats vary a lot.

I have a cat, it does seem to need any of the above. He has got the garden to use as a bathroom. Very rarely sick, he visits the Vet occasionnally, and does not need grooming. He is usually out at night, he is completely white so shows up if there is a bit of light about. He is very independent, but he always get taken to a cattery if I go on holiday.
I suppose that means he is just an animal who seeks food and shelter at my house. :tongue:
 

kyuss

Veteran
Location
Edinburgh
I'm definitely a dog guy. They're a bit daft and hard work but totally devoted in a way that cats will never be. Don't get me wrong I do like cats but after looking after my sister in law's for 2 weeks I don't think I could have one full time. I just always felt like it was 'up to something'.

Seen this a while back which sums it up perfectly for me:

“Excerpts From The Dog’s Daily Diary”
8:00 am - Oh Boy! Dog food! My favorite!
9:30 am - Oh Boy! A car ride! My favorite!
9:40 am - Oh Boy! A walk! My favorite!
10:30 am - Oh Boy! A car ride! My favorite!
11:30 am - Oh Boy! Dog food! My favorite!
Noon - Oh Boy! The kids! My favorite!
1:00 pm - Oh Boy! The yard! My favorite!
4:00 pm - Oh Boy! The kids! My favorite!
5:00 pm - Oh Boy! Dog food! My favorite!
5:30 pm - Oh Boy! Mom! My favorite!
6:00 pm - Oh Boy! Playing ball! My favorite!
6:30 pm - Oh Boy! Sleeping in master’s bed! My favorite!


“Excerpts From The Cat’s Daily Diary”
Day 283 Of My Captivity. My captors continue to taunt me with bizarre little dangling objects. They dine lavishly on fresh meat, while I am forced to eat dry cereal. The only thing that keeps me going is the hope of escape, and the mild satisfaction I get from ruining the occasional piece of furniture. Tomorrow I may eat another house plant.

Today my attempt to kill my captors by weaving around their feet while they were walking almost succeeded; must try this at the top of the stairs. In an attempt to disgust and repulse these vile oppressors, I once again induced myself to vomit on their favorite chair; must try this on their bed. Decapitated a mouse and brought them the headless body, in attempt to make them aware of what I am capable of, and to try to strike fear into their hearts. They only cooed and condescended about what a good little cat I was. Hmmm, not working according to plan.

There was some sort of gathering of their accomplices. I was placed in solitary throughout the event. However, I could hear the noise and smell the food. More importantly I overheard that my confinement was due to MY power of “allergies.” Must learn what this is and how to use it to my advantage.

I am convinced the other captives are flunkies and maybe snitches. The dog is routinely released and seems more than happy to return. He is obviously a half-wit. The bird on the other hand has got to be an informant, and speaks with them regularly. I am certain he reports my every move. Due to his current placement in the metal room, his safety is assured. But I can wait, it is only a matter of time. . . .
 

Keith Oates

Janner
Location
Penarth, Wales
I've had both cats and dogs as pets and like them both but if I had to choose just one it would be the Dog!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
 

ChrisKH

Guru
Location
Essex
Neither. Used to have lots of cats as a kid but the fur (I'm completely OCD about cleanliness) used to drive me mad. And cats poo is the stuff of the devil. Dogs smell.

Having said that, I have a real respect for working dogs having lived on a sheep farm for a short while. The dogs were not pets, lived outside in the barn and were only allowed in the farmhouse if it was -10 and then only in the tiled hallway.
 

wafflycat

New Member
ivancarlos said:
Like what? I am getting a vibe here that people who like cats do so because there is less commitment. If you mean cleaning up after them then if you had to then would you still want to own one?

Less commitment...

Let's see..

Several years ago (when Wafflycat Minor was small) I had a chronic illness which kept me virtually bedridden for the best part of a year. During that time Waffles (the now elderly black cat in my avatar) only left my side to eat, drink & use her litter tray. Then she'd come back to me. If someone closed the bedroom door when she was out on litter tray duties, she'd quietly wait outside until someone opened the door for her, then she'd come back to me, sit alongside me, put her head gently on my shoulder and *purr* ever so gently. In a time of great stress she was a wonderful relaxer and source of calm. She is a very, very special cat to me. She's my girl.

A few years ago, Waffles got into an argument with a vehicle of some kind. Cutting a long story short, she had:-

Blown eye (had to be surgically removed)
concussion
jaw 'moved'
broken ribs
pelvis broken in four places so it was completely detached from her spinal column
open fracture of the femur (now has metal pin in said leg)

After her ops, she had six weeks of cage rest. During the time she was at the vets' surgery, I'd go down every morning with a tshirt in which I'd slept, so it had my scent on it, and placed that in her cage, so she could have the scent of her family to help calm her.

I slept on the floor with my hand through the cage bars so she could sleep with her head cradled in my hand. It was the least I could do when she'd kept me going through a chronic, disabling illness.

Now, she is back to being a normal cat, but being elderly, she only has one fang left, as well as only one eye. Doesn't stop her catching mice & climbing trees...

Any animal that comes under my care does not get less commitment - it gets the commitment a family member would. I'm not under any illusions about my animals being my 'babies' they aren't but they are family members, albeit non-human family members, and they get care appropriate to species.

My cats get fed, watered daily, litter trays seen to, worming treatment, flea treatment, annual vaccinations, all are nneutered/speyed, wear collars with ID tags & bells. My cats will come when called (and not just for food) will jump on my knee for a good old cuddle and purr session. Each cat I have has its own disitinct personality - each is different, just like people are different. Waffles is very much my cat - she will seek me out. Francis is an abused stray taken in and he is the sweetest natured cat who acts forever grateful for getting him well (took over a year to get him back to full-health) and Marble, the feral rescue is different again. As for cats not caring about their owners - poppycock - but what is true is that cats are very different to dogs.

My two hens are rescues - came to me bald patches, broken feathers, could hardly walk, had never seen the light of day until I got them, and had been destined for slaughter to be made into stock cubes/pet food/ low-quality chicken pies... Now they are fully feathered, checked over every day for signs of illness, parasites - are wormed every month, hen house cleaned daily, run cleaned daily, fed & watered daily, allowed to free-range in the garden daily..

If anyone gets *any* pet because they are some sort of 'less commitment' then I would ask them to question this and think about whether they should have the animal at all.
 
Top Bottom