Not having read all 27 pages, has everyone agreed what a BSO is? Do you mean a double sprung 50 lb behemoth, or simply any cheap bike? And what price point denotes cheap and is it just supermarkets who sell them or anywhere that isn't an LBS?
My sister-in-law bought a hybrid from Decathlon a few years ago for around £70 (I forget the exact amount) and joined my wife and I on a Scottish tour. Although she was/is a complete non-cyclist nothing broke and the only maintenance I did was the stuff you'd expect like adjusting cables for brake block wear. It had unbranded equipment but derailleurs changed gear, wheels revolved, brakes braked, the usual things you'd expect a bike to do.
It was not much heavier than similar bikes and she kept up pretty well and seemed to enjoy herself.
I'd suggest that it isn't price per se that makes a bike bad but the expectations one might have of it. Do bikes really break after one trip round the car park? At the very cheapest level they almost match bike hire prices, something to roll up a few miles of country trail and back as a holiday expenditure, a consumer item, a bit of fun?
My sister-in-law bought a hybrid from Decathlon a few years ago for around £70 (I forget the exact amount) and joined my wife and I on a Scottish tour. Although she was/is a complete non-cyclist nothing broke and the only maintenance I did was the stuff you'd expect like adjusting cables for brake block wear. It had unbranded equipment but derailleurs changed gear, wheels revolved, brakes braked, the usual things you'd expect a bike to do.
It was not much heavier than similar bikes and she kept up pretty well and seemed to enjoy herself.
I'd suggest that it isn't price per se that makes a bike bad but the expectations one might have of it. Do bikes really break after one trip round the car park? At the very cheapest level they almost match bike hire prices, something to roll up a few miles of country trail and back as a holiday expenditure, a consumer item, a bit of fun?