Some of the list I went through when I was looking for a commuter.
Charge Mixer, Kona Dr Fine, Marin San Selmo, Giant Seek, Cube Hooper, Trek District.
I settled for the Mixer due to the steel frame - Genesis & the Pompetanmine didn't exist back then.
If I was buying now if would be the Pompetamine. Pound for pound, I feel it offers the best bang for buck - steel frame, handbuilt wheels and Avid BB7 brakes on drop bars. Luscious.