smutchin
Cat 6 Racer
- Location
- The Red Enclave
Enjoying seeing the pictures of the city of Bergen - it's a fantastic looking place.
Is that the city of Bergen in the country of Norway? </sherwen>
Enjoying seeing the pictures of the city of Bergen - it's a fantastic looking place.
Not at all, just reminding him that cycling has been around for a long time with many great champions.You might have missed Smutchin's point!
@gavroche I'm not the one who needs telling that.
Ok pal, we get you have a blog. I read one article you linked to in another thread and it was mildly interesting.
Now this is a forum for talking about things vaguely representing cycling.
So in the future would you just mind posting your opinions or factual representations on here rather than on a 3rd party provider please.
Thanks for your responses
This bit ^^ ........I have heard of Ancquetil in fact(!), and, for what it's worth, I have been following the sport all my life.
.......doesn't fit in with this bit ^^Not many riders in the history of the sport have had the kind of all-round ability in grand tours Froome has.
Get over yourself and post your thoughts on the appropriate threads and you'll be more than welcome here.aaagghhhhh.. I thought I'd bowed out, but I'm tearing my hair out. I've just got to wade back in.
Let's just go back to the statement that drew disagreement/criticism - that's what I'm referring back to when I say 'kind of all-round ability':
Rarely in the history of the sport have we seen a rider with such pure talent in both the fundamental disciplines of grand tour riding
--'both the fundamental disciplines of grand tour riding' - yes, these are the key skills; yes, the great grand tour riders have almost all combined them pretty damn well. It's very obvious that being an all-rounder is key to winning grand tours! And that fact is implicit in what I said..
--'such pure talent' - not even 'pure'.. 'such pure'. All the guys listed above and many more besides have had talent in both disciplines.. many have had pure talent..
You could name Porte and Dumoulin too..
I'm talking about fine, fine degrees of a given quality. And what I'm saying is that, from the moment of his emergence in 2011, Froome has shown an extra special ability to function at the same time as both as a true grimpeur and rouleur. On his day, he has been able to compete with and overcome specialists in both disciplines.
That kind of talent is quite clearly not unprecedented or unequalled, and I never suggested it was. However, to throw Froome in with guys like Wiggins, Evans, Ulrich etc. is hard to justify. They were wonderful GT riders, but Froome is a level above in that discipline. Evans was a diesel who limited his losses as best he could in the hills and finally got a chance to win a (deserved) TdF after years of honest toil. Wiggins bent over backwards to lose enough weight and get himself up the climbs fast enough to live with the specialists. But Wiggins wasn't a true climber.. he didn't have a turn of speed to do damage on a climb. Froome nursed him up the climbs in 2012.
Froome won the yellow and the polkadot in the same edition (2015).. he once destroyed Quintana up Ventoux... and he's a double olympic bronze medallist in the ITT.
(I know it sounds like I'm loving on him, but he is, by his record (which, as yet, stands intact), indisputably one of the greatest ever.)
At the end of the day, these riders are separated by tiny margins.. they are/were all phenomenal all-rounders. But several of those you name have won half or less the TdFs Froome has accumulated and, viewed objectively, occupy a different tier of GT history.
For the time being, I stand by what I said.. in terms of combining such pure talent as a climber and a tester, Froome is a rare phenomenon. Being rare probably helps you to become the fifth most successful rider in TdF history and do a double no-one in the modern era has achieved.. that's quite rare itself!
I might very well be wrong. What's bothering me is that, as things stand, people have been busy pouring scorn on things/ideas I never actually said!!