Randochap said:
The OP isn't a time-trialist riding at 50 km/h. Aerodynamics aren't part of the equation.
There's nothing theoretical about the fact that wider tyres have lower rolling resistance. Rotating mass isn't worth an ounce of coon sh!t on tour -- comfort and rolling resistance is paramount.
Sorry I didn't mean to suggest that the OP was time trialling. Merely putting forward some evidence that wider tyres are not quicker.
I fully agree with your comments on wider tyres for touring. When you've got X kg of luggage in your panniers a few grams on the wheels is neither here nor there and certainly not worth sacrificing comfort for. However, I don't class 70miles unlaiden as a tour. It's just a long Sunday morning ride. Something I wouldn't hesitate to use narrow tyres for.
Each to their own I suppose. Thats one of the best things about cyclechat. loads of riding styles and therefore loads of different opinions on stuff like this!