Road Position - rural roads

Page may contain affiliate links. Please see terms for details.

Bicycle

Guest
I don't want to kick off some sort of polemic here, but I am curious and would like to hear the views of other cyclists.

I'm a middle-aged cyclist with two sons still at home who are more and more inclined to use bicycles for fitness training. As I ride quite a lot, they come out with me (together or singly). One is 12 the other 16. We all tend to ride one kind of road bike or another.

We live in the hilly part where the Three Counties meet and most of the good riding is on sinuous, rolling, single-carriageway, NSL, A-Roads. Cars often pass us at 60-80 mph.

The riding here is good and all my children enjoy it. I've taught the kids to ride as I do, but I see from some posts in other threads that there is a significant weight of opinion holding that my positioning is flawed. As I'm teaching it to my loved ones, I'd be glad of some views.

I ride like this: Usually about 15" from the painted line marking the edge of the carriageway. I tend to be on roads I know and often on roads where I and my boys know the drain covers and potholes. I look behind me often (childhood riding in Central london and years as a courier) and where there's room I go round poor surfaces rather than over them. I'm big on doorzones, but there isn't much stationary traffic between towns. I do not ride like this in towns or cities.

My object on rural roads is to make good progress (I tend to push quite a lot) without holding up motorised traffic. Approaching a right turn off a fast A-Road, I slow well before my turning to allow me time to find a gap in the traffic to pull across. I indicate early, but if there is someone close behind me I wait for him to pass before sticking an arm out.

I read lots of posts about being exposed to gravel if riding close to the white line, but this has not been my experience. I teach the boys to look for gravel and loose/broken surfaces and avoid where possible, but 15" from the white line there is very little loose stuff.

Occasionally, on a fast descent (40-ish mph), I will move out about a third of the way across my lane. Not always, but sometimes. Never,ever much under 40. This seems reasonable as it will not slow other road users down too much and to be frank I have limited braking options from those speeds and loss of control is likely if I have a mechanical failure. My boys don't really crack much over 33 yet, so I still stay out of the traffic with them (but quite far apart).

I am a driver too. Like many cyclists, I like to do what I can to allow the traffic around me to flow freely. Some cyclists consider this unassertive, but it just seems a real-world compromise and a matter of courtesy.

I'll ping this post now and will be interested to see what sort of constructive advice it elicits. I tend to like my own way as it has got me from childhood to almost 50, but I see that the roads have changed and there may be a case for thinking these things out some more.
 

gaz

Cycle Camera TV
Location
South Croydon
Road position is never black and white. There are a lot of factors that affect where you position your self.
 

GrumpyGregry

Here for rides.
On the roads described NSL single carriageways A/B roads I say 'each to their own'. I try not to ride on the ones like that here for recreation but do use some of them for commuting. They vary so much from one locality to another who can call it on raods they are unfamiliar with.

One thing I will say though, and it may sound unduly bloody-minded, but not slowing motor vehicles down is the least of my considerations on these roads and so rarely enters my thinking on rural roads. Even my pile o' garbage sub-1000cc car has what? 50 times my power output, overtaking is easy, when it isn't appropriate they have to wait. Same as they do for horses, tractors, vintage/classic cars, pony'n'traps, etc., etc.
 
I think on little country lanes, with little or no traffic, I'm central avoiding potholes and improving my visability to/from things and what traffic you do come across apreciate it more when you do move. I wish urbanites could take a leaf out of their book. For everything in between road/ traffic wise it varies like Gaz says.
 
You sound an eminently sensible chap, the only thing I would add, and you may already do this is avoid riding into a low sun where possible and always have your boys in front of you. One other thing I do on the rare occasion I ride on an A road, is to monitor approaching traffic from the front, if a car is coming up from behind and one from the front I will move a bit further out to prevent the close pass. If you are ever in this situation on a tightish A road and one of your lads has to swerve out round a pothole you will appreciate the wisdom of blocking that close pass.
 

Matthew_T

"Young and Ex-whippet"
I know a rider (Jon Harland) who lost his son a few years ago. The kid went to my high school (didnt know him) and there was a memorial made in the garden area.
Jon and Tom (his son) were on a club ride on a rural road (a large B road) when a car came hurtling around a corner, skidded in the wet, and went straight into Tom. Jon was on the scene and I cannot imagine what he felt like. The lad lost his life in the ambulance.

From then on, Jon started Junior training sessions at the weekend to increase the amount of skill local young cyclists had on the roads, and in groups. I went to these (until I was too old) and really enjoyed the rides we usually had along the coast at the end of each month.
Jon was always very wary of what everyone was doing in the sessions and always took great care to avoid roads as much as possible. Jon is a great guy and its a shame things like that happen to good people.

If Jon could see some of the filtering I do nowadays (sometimes in the face of oncoming traffic), he would probably kidnap me and lock me in a cell for my own safety.


I don't mean to worry you but I just thought I would share this with everyone.

When riding on rural roads, I tend to keep as close to the verge as possible. On single track, I often dismiss any close pass I come across as I can understand that there is nowhere for the driver to go.
 
Eeeh - nothing to add at all. Sounds like common sense :thumbsup: - which is just a daft way of saying I do pretty much the same. Riding "comfortable" country roads is different - a bit of stepping back in time. And generally, you have a lot more time to be aware of other users.

I'd a brilliant BMW driver yesterday; OK, perhaps not so brilliant - he was so cautious that I had to signal him to pass, but what a pleasant change.

+1 on your position though; when my four were your sons' ages, I did like totallyfixed - riding behind them always, and often just that bit further out to block the close passes. [I'm still always behind them, but now it's because they're faster and fitter :angry:]
 

Nebulous

Guru
Location
Aberdeen
I try to find quiet roads, which is surprisingly easy around here. I can leave my home in the middle of a fairly busy small city and be on quiet roads within 20 minutes. It sounds as though I ride a bit further out than you - about a metre from the edge - we don't often have a white line. If descending quickly I pretty much take the centre of the lane though I rarely have a car anywhere near on a quick descent. One village to the West sits lower than the surrounding area and has a long winding descent. It's possible to average over 30 mph for 3 miles. Once I was taking a corner at over 30 when a motorbike went past me and gunned the engine just as the bend opened up. What a shock I got - as I had been unaware of his presence until then. He must have closed behind me very fast.

I find there are distinct differences in culture in different directions. To the west there is a large cycle club and drivers tend to be fairly understanding. To the North there are fewer cyclists and the drivers are more aggressive.
 
I ride county roads on my rest day rides, and commute through a city. I ride as you do. I find the lesser used country roads tend to be in better condition than the city routes and are more conducive to riding a little further left. I'd still call your (and my) position a good secondary though, and not gutter-riding.
 

Monkspeed

Active Member
Location
Essex, UK
I don't want to kick off some sort of polemic here, but I am curious and would like to hear the views of other cyclists.

I'm a middle-aged cyclist with two sons still at home who are more and more inclined to use bicycles for fitness training. As I ride quite a lot, they come out with me (together or singly). One is 12 the other 16. We all tend to ride one kind of road bike or another.

We live in the hilly part where the Three Counties meet and most of the good riding is on sinuous, rolling, single-carriageway, NSL, A-Roads. Cars often pass us at 60-80 mph.

The riding here is good and all my children enjoy it. I've taught the kids to ride as I do, but I see from some posts in other threads that there is a significant weight of opinion holding that my positioning is flawed. As I'm teaching it to my loved ones, I'd be glad of some views.

I ride like this: Usually about 15" from the painted line marking the edge of the carriageway. I tend to be on roads I know and often on roads where I and my boys know the drain covers and potholes. I look behind me often (childhood riding in Central london and years as a courier) and where there's room I go round poor surfaces rather than over them. I'm big on doorzones, but there isn't much stationary traffic between towns. I do not ride like this in towns or cities.

My object on rural roads is to make good progress (I tend to push quite a lot) without holding up motorised traffic. Approaching a right turn off a fast A-Road, I slow well before my turning to allow me time to find a gap in the traffic to pull across. I indicate early, but if there is someone close behind me I wait for him to pass before sticking an arm out.

I read lots of posts about being exposed to gravel if riding close to the white line, but this has not been my experience. I teach the boys to look for gravel and loose/broken surfaces and avoid where possible, but 15" from the white line there is very little loose stuff.

Occasionally, on a fast descent (40-ish mph), I will move out about a third of the way across my lane. Not always, but sometimes. Never,ever much under 40. This seems reasonable as it will not slow other road users down too much and to be frank I have limited braking options from those speeds and loss of control is likely if I have a mechanical failure. My boys don't really crack much over 33 yet, so I still stay out of the traffic with them (but quite far apart).

I am a driver too. Like many cyclists, I like to do what I can to allow the traffic around me to flow freely. Some cyclists consider this unassertive, but it just seems a real-world compromise and a matter of courtesy.

I'll ping this post now and will be interested to see what sort of constructive advice it elicits. I tend to like my own way as it has got me from childhood to almost 50, but I see that the roads have changed and there may be a case for thinking these things out some more.

Mr B,

I think you are one of those forum members that always speak the truth and always in a sensible and very articulate way. Its good that you are so open minded to ask about this issue but I wouldn't take the comments from everybody so seriously, after all how do you know THEY are doing it right in the first place?

I know your question stems from the other thread of the guy who posted a vid while out on his fixed bike. I though his position looked fine, and the angle of the lens on the camera possibly made him look closer to the hedge than he really was. I noticed a few times that when he looked down he was quite a distance away from the edge of the road and to be honest thats where I would have positioned myself, actually I would probably have been even closer to the line as I hate the thought of inconveniencing other road uses, but that is just my lack of confidence and experience at the moment as I am a relatively new cyclist.

I would say as you have, you have done alright so far up to this point in your life so you must be doing something right, right?. Though, I'm not so sure I would be happy letting my kids cycle on a busy A road with cars going past so fast, this even scares the hell out of me nevermind the children.
 

Mugshot

Cracking a solo.
Mainly country roads on my commute and well.....just about everywhere around here really, I tend to ride around 18/24 inches from the verge, not too many white lines on the commute. So I would imagine that's a resonable secondary. There is a sweeping left hand turn at the top of a hill which I move towards primary for as you can't see on coming traffic.
I have noticed however that my (at the moment) pitch black ride home brings out a different rider in me and I position myself much more towards primary than I do in the murky mornings. I'm not sure that this was a concious decision, it just seems to have developed, but for whatever reason I do not feel as comfortable riding in secondary when it's proper dark. It may be that I'm more confident of drivers seeing me or maybe I'm just scared that the hedge monster will leap out at me:ninja:
 

Bigsharn

Veteran
Location
Leeds
I like the Wetherby back roads, which those on here that know where I mean, will know are single-lane-either-way 60mph roads, and will understand why I ride in primary around the entire thing.

If the roads around your end are busy then I wouldn't recommend riding in primary all the time, but on the quiet ones I stick to the drivers tend to be fine with me being in primary until I can pull over into a safe passing point.
 

Arjimlad

Tights of Cydonia
Location
South Glos
I keep to the rule of the road - keep left unless overtaking... same as you. No need to stay in the middle of the lane unless potholes or road conditions dictate.
 

tyred

Squire
Location
Ireland
Most of my riding is on rural roads of varying widths. I generally ride about 18" to 2' from the edge of the road. On blind left hand corners, I may move further right to make myself more visible to anything approaching from behind.

I often move further right as well if I know there is a car approaching from behind and I consider it too risky for it to overtake me due to on coming traffic. I used to be reluctant to do this as I was worried drivers would be angry at being held up for 10 seconds but it doesn't seem to be the case (apart from the idiot in the Renault van I encountered before Christmas but there is always one).
 
OP
OP
B

Bicycle

Guest
Some very helpful comment - all of it in truth. Thank you all. I am in that odd position where I want my children to be fearless at the same time as wanting them to remain alive and well.

...avoid riding into a low sun where possible and always have your boys in front of you..

You're quite right about the low sun. It's a pet hate of mine but rarely avoidable, particularly between October and February. I used to ride behind (and slightly outside) all of the children, but now we swap positions and are generally more fluid.

(Although when they were younger I always led into roundabouts and asked them to follow me).

We have had some near misses but try and talk through what happened afterwards. I try to resist getting angry with the motorists - I think it sets a bad example and I'd hate my lads to get involved in any road rage situation.

Very helpful comments, these. If the children are 'receptive' (which is not a given) I'll occasionally comment on a close truck pass or similar and give a mini-lecture or Q&A about what to look for and how to respond. A Cadbury's lorry passed on a climb last week where there was only just enough room. I warned boy-younger that he'd swing back in too early if traffic came over the brow. It did. He did. Then the mini-lecture on optimising safety by trying to see what might happen next. Sometimes I really think it's mad to take the kids out on these roads, then I think a life not lived out is worse by a long way.

On blind left hand corners, I may move further right to make myself more visible to anything approaching from behind.

I read this a few times and gave it a lot of thought. It is so emminently sound that I gave it a go. Thanks. I found that it scared the Hell out of me unless I was completely sure who and what was behind me and how fast they were going. I like the principle, so I'll stick at it. I'm concerned that the boys (non-drivers) may not have the necessary awareness of closing speed and how cars respond to input to do this.

I often move further right as well if I know there is a car approaching from behind and I consider it too risky for it to overtake me due to on coming traffic. I used to be reluctant to do this as I was worried drivers would be angry at being held up for 10 seconds but it doesn't seem to be the case (apart from the idiot in the Renault van I encountered before Christmas but there is always one).

Crikey! Another one that got me thinking. I do not think myself an over-caurious rider, but I lack the bottle for this one. The thinking behind it is totally sound, but I'd imagine every driver was your idiot in a Renault van.
 
Top Bottom