Novice on a high end bike

Page may contain affiliate links. Please see terms for details.

alp1950

Well-Known Member
Location
Balmore
Got the opportunity to demo a high end carbon fibre bike today (Trek Madone 5.2). OK I know that it's probably the equivalent of giving an early intermediate tennis player Roger Federer's racket to play with; or intermediate skier Bode Miller's race skis but you're not going to turn down the chance are you?

These are my first experiences. (Bear in mind that although I'm reasonably fit, I've done no fast competitive cycling and most of my road biking experience has been on a 1980s steel framed dropped bar tourer).

Incredibly light of course. Very responsive steering- at times almost too responsive. Several times felt it twitch- almost as though the bike itself was alive (not sure if this was down to me, or whether the bike was caught by a gust of wind). Didn't really appreciate the bike while cycling back through town in moderate traffic- at this point was thinking that it was not really suited to town cycling- or perhaps I didn't have the necessary skills as the bike just seemed too responsive and found myself wanting something heavier and more stable. The fact that I was just getting used to the bike may have had something to do with this; but also the fact that never really got up much speed & kept having to stop at traffic lights meant the bike never had a chance to show off.

However once I got out onto some nice quiet country roads I started to appreciate the bike. What really came through was the speed: impressive on flats; down hills unbelievable. Going up hills was easy, particularly when out of the saddle.

I was looking forward to seeing how smooth the ride would feel. Yes it felt smooth enough, however to be honest it wasn't like the difference between night & day. To be a fair comparison though I need to go back and ride the same routes on my steel framed bike (and also maybe an entry level aluminium frame).

Got the bike for another couple of days. It will be interesting to see how I find the old tourer after the Madone.:biggrin:
 

Cathryn

Legendary Member
When I first got my lovely Thorn tourer, I felt like I'd just passed my driving test and been given a Mercedes! Totally unworthy!! It's a great feeling...
 

Keith Oates

Janner
Location
Penarth, Wales
alp1950, welcome to the feel of a carbon road bike. I think you have already mentioned some of the good feelings you had and for sure if you continue with that bike, or a similar one, the feeling will only get better. When you get to use it for longer rides (50 Km or more) you will really notice and appreciate how good a decent carbon bike is and how much easier and faster it will perform!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
 

Blue

Squire
Location
N Ireland
alp1950 said:
However once I got out onto some nice quiet country roads I started to appreciate the bike. What really came through was the speed: impressive on flats; down hills unbelievable. Going up hills was easy, particularly when out of the saddle.

I was looking forward to seeing how smooth the ride would feel. Yes it felt smooth enough, however to be honest it wasn't like the difference between night & day.

That is what I would say about the difference between my own carbon and alu bikes. I find my carbon is nice, however, my alu bike gives a more 'engaging' ride, which I prefer.

I would only go for a carbon bike if my existing bike was a disappointment - and I wish someone had said that to me before I splashed out :biggrin:
 
OP
OP
alp1950

alp1950

Well-Known Member
Location
Balmore
Having experienced the speeds that can be achieved on carbon road bikes can I ask a stupid question of the racers out there? Presumably most club races are on roads shared with other road users- how often do you deliberately limit your speed simply for safety considerations ie because you just don't know what lunatic car driver might be just round the next corner? Is the fastest time posted by the most reckless (survivor)?
 
Top Bottom