There is an old club in Leicester called The Ratae which has been around for ever, they do a reliability ride, half of which is on A roads. We did this ride a couple of years ago and never again, yet it would have been so easy to plot a very similar route using quiet lanes. Some folk are very resistant to change!
I did the full NWP in 2007 but took one look at the route and decided that it wasn't for me. A long stint on the busy A65, for example, is not my cup of tea. I rode down it from Settle to Gargrave one wet Sunday evening and I have never been that scared on a bike. Visibility was awful with heavy spray from traffic. Many people were clearly returning to Yorkshire from a weekend in the Lake District. Coaches, cars towing horse boxes or boats, juggernauts, white vans ... All were thundering past just inches from my right elbow, often swerving out at the last moment when the drivers saw me emerging from the mist. Very, very scary!
So, I plotted my own route for the NWP between Gisburn and Longridge, taking quiet roads wherever sensible options were available. It added a few kms to the route and some extra climbing, but I managed to avoid a lot of busy roads. Not the climb of the A682 from Barrowford, however. I don't know if it still holds, but in 2007, the A682 held the title of
Britain's Most Dangerous Road!
Road Safety Foundation for the European Road Assessment Programme (EuroRAP) said:
Britain's most dangerous road is a section of highway linking Lancashire and the Yorkshire Dales, a survey says.
The 15-mile stretch of the A682 has had almost 100 deaths or serious injuries in the last decade.
Not the most desirable choice of route for an audax, one might think?
Still, perhaps the report was exaggerating the dangers?
Or, perhaps not ...!
ColinJ on BikeRadar in 2007 said:
I rode the 200 km North-West Passage audax on February 17th this year and that goes up the A682, 'most dangerous road in the UK'. I'd heard of the reputation of the A682 but was prepared to see for myself. Here is part of an email I wrote to a friend about what I saw that day:
"I thought the A682 was a nice road scenically, but I'm afraid that the traffic certainly lived up to its awful reputation... I personally saw some examples of stupid speeding, and reckless overtaking, but what I heard about later would take some beating. I turned left at Gisburn for my lanes route to Settle, to avoid further time on the A-roads. I spotted some toilets there so I stopped to refill one of my bottles. Just before I remounted, a group of about 6 fellow audaxers appeared - they had obviously decided to minimise time spent on the A-roads as well. One older guy was really agitated, and was cursing a farmer whose vehicle had just collided with him! Apparently, the farmer decided that it was perfectly okay to overtake on a blind bend. That was bad enough, but made far worse by the fact that he was towing a big livestock trailer with a cow in it. Suddenly a vehicle appeared from the opposite direction, so the farmer swerved left to avoid a head-on collision. His trailer side-swiped the old cyclist and pushed him off the road. Clearly, the outcome could have been much worse than the bruised arm he'd suffered. The group's combined shouts had no effect on the farmer who merely carried on his way as if nothing had happened..."
So as far as I'm concerned, from what I saw and heard in just one ride - yes, due to the stupidity and/or death wishes of many of the drivers you may encounter there - the A682 can be a dodgy place to spend a Saturday morning!
My safety tips:
(1) Take an alternative route!
(2) Drive a tank!
As for folk being resistant to change ... When I got to the control at Kirkby Lonsdale, I had a word with the organisers. They had been worried that I'd taken so long for me to get there from Settle. Had I suffered mechanical problems? I explained that I'd been meandering round the lanes rather than dicing with traffic on the A682 and A65. The guy looked at me as if I was a crazy man and asked me what was wrong with the A65!
I spoke to an old cyclist in Hebden Bridge once. He'd been riding in this area for over 20 years and the only route he ever did was Hebden Bridge - A629 - Keighley - B6265 - Cross Hills - A6088 - Colne - A56 - Nelson - A682 - Burnley - A6114/A646 - Todmorden, Hebden Bridge! He had never once ventured up onto the glorious local hilly minor roads. It's sad.
I met another man who only used to ride from Hebden Bridge to Todmorden, to Walk Mill on the A646 and then turn round and ride home.
I really don't get those people! Still, it takes all sorts ... My forum rides are an attempt to get people off the A-roads and to do some exploring that they otherwise might not have done.