'Fixed' bikes...
- Thread starter yenrod
- Start date
Page may contain affiliate links. Please see terms for details.
Rhythm Thief
Legendary Member
- Location
- Ross on Wye
got-to-get-fit said:
It's not about "zen", whatever that is. It's just fun, that's all.
twentysix by twentyfive
Clinging on tightly
- Location
- Over the Hill
domtyler said:??? You have to stop quickly at junctions and clip in when moving off on a normal geared bike don't you?
Naa - just jump thro' those red lights like all the others
saves having to clip in all the time 
Mine frightened the crap out of me at first. I very nearly sold it... but I persevered. Personally, I do find it a completely different experience to riding with gears and/or freewheel. The terms 'connected' and 'zen' might sound wanky but they do have a meaning for me that I associate with riding fixed. You do feel as if you a part of the bike; your legs being part of the drive chain. Hill climbing is somehow easier as you know what you have to do; the choice of gear removed, you just keep turning the pedals. There is a direct drive on fixed that translates every pedal stroke into power on the road, and conversely you 'feel' the road with every turn of the pedal. It is simply intoxicating.
I accept that some people find it fun and enjoy the "different" riding experience, but there does seem to be a lot of mumbo-jumbo non-reasons for them still being bandied about.
The "Less to go wrong" argument is bollocks unless the amount of stuff to go wrong with a geared bike is burdensome, which it isn't.
"Choice of gear removed" is only an advantage if you're indecisive about what gear to use otherwise.
etc...
And then these arguments make me think that people are inventing them because there ARE NO other reasons, which makes me suspicious of even the 'fun in a weird way' bit, the only possibly valid argument for them. If people could just state that they're 'fun in a weird way' and just leave it at that?
The "Less to go wrong" argument is bollocks unless the amount of stuff to go wrong with a geared bike is burdensome, which it isn't.
"Choice of gear removed" is only an advantage if you're indecisive about what gear to use otherwise.
etc...
And then these arguments make me think that people are inventing them because there ARE NO other reasons, which makes me suspicious of even the 'fun in a weird way' bit, the only possibly valid argument for them. If people could just state that they're 'fun in a weird way' and just leave it at that?
Bonj, as you've quoted me, I'll respond...
There is less to go wrong, fullstop. Whether it's burdensome or not is another issue. Agreed, it's not difficult to adjust the front/rear dérailleurs on a geared bike...but it's something that one needn't do at all on fixed!
You're missing the point. It's not a matter of being decisive or not, as there is no decision to make on fixed. On a geared bike you make a decision, however spontaneously, whatever it is, even it it's to stay in the same gear. As the question doesn't even arise on fixed, there is nothing to be decided.
Perhaps it sounds like bollocks to you but I find there is a very different feel to riding fixed. Yes, it is weird (and fun) - the descriptions you read are fixed riders trying to be a little more descriptive than simply saying "it's weird". After all, 'weird' is not really a particularly helpful description for someone interested in what it's like to ride fixed.
There is less to go wrong, fullstop. Whether it's burdensome or not is another issue. Agreed, it's not difficult to adjust the front/rear dérailleurs on a geared bike...but it's something that one needn't do at all on fixed!
You're missing the point. It's not a matter of being decisive or not, as there is no decision to make on fixed. On a geared bike you make a decision, however spontaneously, whatever it is, even it it's to stay in the same gear. As the question doesn't even arise on fixed, there is nothing to be decided.
Perhaps it sounds like bollocks to you but I find there is a very different feel to riding fixed. Yes, it is weird (and fun) - the descriptions you read are fixed riders trying to be a little more descriptive than simply saying "it's weird". After all, 'weird' is not really a particularly helpful description for someone interested in what it's like to ride fixed.
yello - I'm not disputing the facts themselves, I'm disputing why it's an advantage.
Ease of maintenance and lack of needing to decide what gear to be in don't really appear to be attempting to describe fun of riding, more of an attempt to fabricate evidence of some significant technical advantage which has no substance.
it's not - because if it isn't burdensome, then it isn't a significant advantage. So therefore there's no point in saying it, which makes it sound like a made-up advantage, which makes me think there aren't any REAL advantages, even though there might well be, just not that are tangible in an on-paper sense.yello said:
Again, and that's an advantage because...?yello said:
Now that is the only bit that doesn't sound like bollocks. The above two paragraphs sound like bollocks.yello said:
Ease of maintenance and lack of needing to decide what gear to be in don't really appear to be attempting to describe fun of riding, more of an attempt to fabricate evidence of some significant technical advantage which has no substance.
Dave5N
Über Member
- Location
- Outside The Little Nibble
Why don't you lot come and have a day on the track and see how much your skills develop?
Closing event: the Cyclechat Madison?
Closing event: the Cyclechat Madison?
bonj said:
Ah well, that's different. If you don't accept them as advantages then fair enough. Maybe, for you, there is no advantage to riding fixed. In many circumstances, there are none.
But if you want to know why it's enjoyable then you're into an even more subjective area. You're back into 'zen' and 'connected'... which you may have even less time for! If you don't already ride fixed then give it a go. Answer the question for yourself.
Reminds me of the Louis Armstrong quote; "If you have to ask what jazz is, you'll never know."
iandg
Legendary Member
- Location
- Dumfries and Galloway
marketing, a trend started by couriers? I'm 47 and have had a fixed in my collection since I was 14 - long before the current fashion started - I did race the track as a youngster and there was a general practice of riding fixed in the winter for 'clubmen'.
Good for climbing (look at the national hill climb results), maintaining momentum in a head wind and great for commuting. Far less maintenance, less to go wrong, and less to be tampered with when you leave it outside work all day
Good for climbing (look at the national hill climb results), maintaining momentum in a head wind and great for commuting. Far less maintenance, less to go wrong, and less to be tampered with when you leave it outside work all day
piedwagtail91
Guest
riding fixed has been a winter tradition in the touring club for well over 40 years, there have always been at least 4 on fixed. recently we had about 7.though i think i'm one of only two who have used it all year round.
Dayvo
just passin' through
- Location
- 59° 50′ 5.55″ N, 10° 47′ 41.89″ E
Dave5N said:
It won't develop his social skills, though!
