Drink or no drink?

Page may contain affiliate links. Please see terms for details.

Traininghigh

New Member
Location
Barcelona
Traditionally, endurance sports had been encouraged to drink drink moderately high amounts in order to prevent loss of fluid. However, there is no clear consensus on the real need for these recommendations. In addition, the replacement of sodium through commercial beverages industry has popularized the commercial sports drinks with the idea of preventing hyponatremia.
To this question several questions arise:
1) What is optimum amount of liquid in each person and in different environmental conditions?
2) replacement of minerals is required to prevent hyponatremia?
3) What grade affects athletic performance dehydration?

Based on these general questions, descriptive way you can target:
1) As the temperature and the humidity is higher increases fluid loss of body weight loss increased. General recommendations suggest intake of 150-250 ml every 15 minutes of exercise (between 800-1200 ml per hour) to avoid exceeding 2% dehydration is related to the decrease in athletic performance (SJ Montain, 2008) . However, other studies point in the opposite direction showing that further dehydration to 2% does not reduce athletic performance (Maciejczyk M., 2014). A prominent scientist Tim Noakes in their, widely defends the intake of fluids and salts excessively is not necessary and that athletic performance and health is most at risk with increased intake of fluids and salts (T Noakes , 2011).
2) In a recent scientific review suggests that replenishment of fluid and minerals should be done according to individual responses and environmental conditions (Baker L, 2014). Importantly, increasingly, both athletic training and nutritional recommendations for individual response monitoring of physiological responses and improved athletic performance is employed.
3) Parace important to highlight the importance of the duration of the sporting event to draw important conclusions on the subject. For example, it seems obvious to think that evidence of close to 1 or 2 hours duration, the replacement of fluids and salts is not as important as in testing more than 3 hours (T Noakes, 2011). The physiological explanation for this point is that despite the sodium lost through sweat, if we increase fluid intake rapidly increases the chance of developing hyponatremia.

In conclusion, each athlete should estimate its perceptual and objective response of athletic performance test based on their own individual response with a higher intake of fluid and salt or less.
Note that in the high-performance sports when exercise intensity is high there is an excessive attachment to the following popular beverage intake recommendations every 15 minutes or 1200ml per per hour. Therefore, it is probable risk in athletes ingesting high amount of fluid and salts.
 
What? . :wacko:
 

ianrauk

Tattooed Beat Messiah
Location
Rides Ti2


Father_jack.jpg
 

cosmicbike

Perhaps This One.....
Moderator
Location
Egham
Traditionally, endurance sports had been encouraged to drink drink moderately high amounts in order to prevent loss of fluid. However, there is no clear consensus on the real need for these recommendations. In addition, the replacement of sodium through commercial beverages industry has popularized the commercial sports drinks with the idea of preventing hyponatremia.
To this question several questions arise:
1) What is optimum amount of liquid in each person and in different environmental conditions?
2) replacement of minerals is required to prevent hyponatremia?
3) What grade affects athletic performance dehydration?

Based on these general questions, descriptive way you can target:
1) As the temperature and the humidity is higher increases fluid loss of body weight loss increased. General recommendations suggest intake of 150-250 ml every 15 minutes of exercise (between 800-1200 ml per hour) to avoid exceeding 2% dehydration is related to the decrease in athletic performance (SJ Montain, 2008) . However, other studies point in the opposite direction showing that further dehydration to 2% does not reduce athletic performance (Maciejczyk M., 2014). A prominent scientist Tim Noakes in their, widely defends the intake of fluids and salts excessively is not necessary and that athletic performance and health is most at risk with increased intake of fluids and salts (T Noakes , 2011).
2) In a recent scientific review suggests that replenishment of fluid and minerals should be done according to individual responses and environmental conditions (Baker L, 2014). Importantly, increasingly, both athletic training and nutritional recommendations for individual response monitoring of physiological responses and improved athletic performance is employed.
3) Parace important to highlight the importance of the duration of the sporting event to draw important conclusions on the subject. For example, it seems obvious to think that evidence of close to 1 or 2 hours duration, the replacement of fluids and salts is not as important as in testing more than 3 hours (T Noakes, 2011). The physiological explanation for this point is that despite the sodium lost through sweat, if we increase fluid intake rapidly increases the chance of developing hyponatremia.

In conclusion, each athlete should estimate its perceptual and objective response of athletic performance test based on their own individual response with a higher intake of fluid and salt or less.
Note that in the high-performance sports when exercise intensity is high there is an excessive attachment to the following popular beverage intake recommendations every 15 minutes or 1200ml per per hour. Therefore, it is probable risk in athletes ingesting high amount of fluid and salts.
Maybe...
Is tea ok, 'cos that's all I put in my bottles. With milk and 2.
 

Cubist

Still wavin'
Location
Ovver 'thill
 

Joshua Plumtree

Approaching perfection from a distance.
So, in conclusion, each and everyone of us will require slightly differing amounts of hydration, and this in turn will be affected by how hot or cold it is and how hard we're working.

How much did this research cost? :wacko:
 

Saluki

World class procrastinator
I take a couple of bottles of water with me, I drink when required and top up when necessary. To top up, knock on someone's door and ask politely. Never been refused yet.
I am sure that there is a ton of science involved in proper hydration, I read most of your post @Traininghigh but was rapidly losing the will to live as I don't compete any more, I just ride my bike for as long as I like, when I like. It seems like a plan.

Welcome to CC by the way. Enjoy your riding.
 

Saluki

World class procrastinator
I am not sure that training high will ever be back to answer that one.
Strange sort of a post for a troll though. Normally trolls post the whole 'all cyclists who wear padded shorts are a bit thick' or whatever type of posts. They don't come on here and give us collective brain ache about hydration.
 

KneesUp

Guru
1) As the temperature and the humidity is higher increases fluid loss of body weight loss increased.
2) In a recent scientific review suggests that replenishment of fluid and minerals should be done according to individual responses and environmental conditions
3) ...highlight the importance of the duration of the sporting event to draw important conclusions on the subject. For example, it seems obvious to think that evidence of close to 1 or 2 hours duration, the replacement of fluids and salts is not as important as in testing more than 3 hours.

1) If it's hot you need to drink more
2) The amount you need to drink depends somewhat on how you respond to heat, and how hot it is
3) If you exercise for longer, you will need to drink more.
4) Why did no-one tell me at school it was this easy to be a scientist?
 
OP
OP
T

Traininghigh

New Member
Location
Barcelona
here, the principal problem is that time before endurance athletes was encouraged to drink regularly during exercise without take in account the fitness level, the weather or time of event. Industries of drinks have promoted studies that reinforce their hypothesis but, human physiology is largely predisposed to drink great quantities of liquid. The question is: what reduce more the performance: deshydratation or overhydratation? And, what is the risks for the health?
 
Top Bottom