HobbesOnTour
Guru
- Location
- España
I wasn't really questioning my Irishness. I do recall a few years ago considering applying for a Dutch passport (they allow you to have two!) but quickly gave up on that idea when I realised I'd have to surrender my Irish one.
A little bit of history and a bit of travel soon educates us that our current "nationalities" are pretty modern concepts and a lot derived from lines drawn on a map.
From my own area of interest, there are often debates about the origins of whisk(e)y - Ireland or Scotland. Back in the day there was constant, seasonal migration from Northern Ireland to Scotland and vice versa. Our "modern" concept of these two nations don't easily process that. It has to be one or the other.
Then throw in ideas that are propogated for other means and the whole thing gets very, very complicated.
Again, staying with whiskey, it is commonly thought a significant difference between Irish & Scotch is in the number of distillations (Ireland 3, Scotland 2), or the ingredients used (only barley in Scotland, a mix of grains in Ireland). But that's simply not true, historically, and is often used as a marketing advantage these days. Imagine what cunning political leaders could do manipulating ideas of nationality, nationhood and sovereignty?
Until relatively recently, Germany as a nation did not exist. There were people who spoke German in lots of independent states, provinces & cities. Today, not all German speakers are German! They are Italians or Belgians or even French!!
And look at Belgium! Split between a Dutch & French side. And that split is real and tangible!
We are what we are by an accident of birth. It's good to know where we came from because that's history and history is very important.
A little bit of history and a bit of travel soon educates us that our current "nationalities" are pretty modern concepts and a lot derived from lines drawn on a map.
From my own area of interest, there are often debates about the origins of whisk(e)y - Ireland or Scotland. Back in the day there was constant, seasonal migration from Northern Ireland to Scotland and vice versa. Our "modern" concept of these two nations don't easily process that. It has to be one or the other.
Then throw in ideas that are propogated for other means and the whole thing gets very, very complicated.
Again, staying with whiskey, it is commonly thought a significant difference between Irish & Scotch is in the number of distillations (Ireland 3, Scotland 2), or the ingredients used (only barley in Scotland, a mix of grains in Ireland). But that's simply not true, historically, and is often used as a marketing advantage these days. Imagine what cunning political leaders could do manipulating ideas of nationality, nationhood and sovereignty?
Until relatively recently, Germany as a nation did not exist. There were people who spoke German in lots of independent states, provinces & cities. Today, not all German speakers are German! They are Italians or Belgians or even French!!
And look at Belgium! Split between a Dutch & French side. And that split is real and tangible!
We are what we are by an accident of birth. It's good to know where we came from because that's history and history is very important.