who said any thing about money,you keep your opinions to your self if you can't be positive,I have been positive to the op and yet a keyboard warrior wants to battle,motivation is were its at,to make a athlete their is more than one way to get results
don't bother coming back with another snide comment i am not going to respond
I stand by the comment too - If I was paying someone to "train" me and that was the advice given,I would demand my money back. In fact even if it was free I'd walk away.
Please have a go at addressing some of the issues below,I believe I have made reasonable attempt to be constructive and give good sound reason.
Good luck stick with it ,remember if you have a bad weigh in muscle weighs more than fat and you will develop lean muscle
Only by volume.
and not wanting to over complicate replies
I can see sense in this, but my not wanting to complicate replies you actually got the reply,incredibly factually wrong. It's indefensible when giving other people advice.
the advice you get on a forum is just that advice,not gospel
That doesn't mean you give any old advice you can think of and hope it sticks. I honestly couldn't sleep at night if I thought any advice I gave on the internet (in my own free time and of free will of course) was incorrect, inconsistent or potentially damaging to the recipients health. I may be a keyboard warrior, but I'm not going to bullshit people around when it comes to exercise,diet,health and weightloss. Nor am I going to say nothing when I see bad or illt-thought advice. As hard as it may seem, I care about people, pseudonyms or otherwise.
unless you have a full over view on the situation,what works for one may not work for others
Here is the overview: Cycling forum - endurance sport - carbs are good - sustainable deficits to lose weight healthily and sustainably. Bad diet can't be out-exercised and is 80% of the issue when it comes to fitness,endurance and weightloss.
forums allow you to gather information and use the information to make a informed decision
And forums also allow the asking of questions. Those questions should really have the best answers available. Full,detailed and factually correct answers.
there is no need to doubt members knowledge,
There is every need when resulting advice could potentially cause harm to another human being who takes it literally in good faith. All too often on here (and other forums) this "eat less - move more" thing crops up. While not complicated it doesn't take into account that the recipient of the advice, may well not be able to eat less. Sometimes advice is generic,but sometimes you need to dig deeper in order to personalise it.