Best Andorid App to replace a bike computer and GPS

Page may contain affiliate links. Please see terms for details.

John the Monkey

Frivolous Cyclist
Location
Crewe
I don't disagree with your synopsis, and appreciate that many people love their Garmin - but I do get annoyed when someone asks for advice about what phone apps to get and then get bombarded with advice to buy a Garmin. It's a bit like the what Android phone should I get?....Answer - Get an iPhone 5.
:biggrin:

I'm thinking through the pros and cons myself at the moment. I've used a Galaxy S4 for a while (as a recorder for Endomondo &c), but I'm tempted by something I can use screen on for long periods of time, I must say.
 

uclown2002

Guru
Location
Harrogate
Has anyone mentioned just getting a Garmin instead?
 
Location
Pontefract
depends how cheap is, you can pick up garmin edge 705's for less than £100, mine was 45+pp did need a little sorting like an adaptor for the mount (already got some quarter turn mounts) a new battery, maps can be got free and are easy to install, ok the screen is smaller, but does everything I need, including hr sp/cad, if I tweak it enough I am sure it will ride the bike for me as well.:whistle:
 

John the Monkey

Frivolous Cyclist
Location
Crewe
depends how cheap is, you can pick up garmin edge 705's for less than £100, mine was 45+pp did need a little sorting like an adaptor for the mount (already got some quarter turn mounts) a new battery, maps can be got free and are easy to install, ok the screen is smaller, but does everything I need, including hr sp/cad, if I tweak it enough I am sure it will ride the bike for me as well.:whistle:
Interesting - those were the first to do navigation as well, weren't they? Does it do route calculation, or just following a GPX course? (sorry for the thread hijack, op - some mounts for my phone cost £40, so this is interesting stuff)
 
OP
OP
KneesUp

KneesUp

Guru
I can see the point of trying to use the nav & tracking functions of your phone so you only have to carry a single device, but you want to carry two phones, one as phone, one as GPS - for which it will always be suboptimal, whichever apps you use.

Get Martin's Legend HCx, or an Etrex 10 *** if the ££ are an issue, for less than the cost of a decent phone it will do most of what you want (navigation and recording tracks) very well indeed. If you want extra features like heart rate then wait until you can afford a more expensive GPS.

*** both of which can load FREE maps from OSM

But I can get a ruggedised phone for £60 or so, which if/when I ever get to go on a tour can also be used as an ereader and camera and - well anything else I get the apps for. A bike computer and a phone are basically just computers - but the one labelled as a 'phone' can be used to run all sorts of programs. And of course I'd have a spare phone :smile:
 
OP
OP
KneesUp

KneesUp

Guru
Interesting - those were the first to do navigation as well, weren't they? Does it do route calculation, or just following a GPX course? (sorry for the thread hijack, op - some mounts for my phone cost £40, so this is interesting stuff)
No problem.

Have you seen Finn as a mount?

 
Location
Pontefract
But I can get a ruggedised phone for £60 or so, which if/when I ever get to go on a tour can also be used as an ereader and camera and - well anything else I get the apps for. A bike computer and a phone are basically just computers - but the one labelled as a 'phone' can be used to run all sorts of programs. And of course I'd have a spare phone :smile:
If I take pictures I want a camera, phones just don't have the quality..

Interesting - those were the first to do navigation as well, weren't they? Does it do route calculation, or just following a GPX course? (sorry for the thread hijack, op - some mounts for my phone cost £40, so this is interesting stuff)
You can load either tcx or gpx course/route files, tcx for training with a virtual partner, the gpx route will give you turn advise notice at about 1/5 of a mile and at the turn, it will calculate a route for you (various settings) I have tried the get home feature and whilst it works my local knowledge is sometimes better, but it could be settings or the map, I have a few different ones and currently using one with elevation lines, though it must be quite old as a by pass I came down today gave an error. I tend to use tcx course files but I will be trying out the gpx route file option a little more. The new battery as with all lithium batteries took a few charges to get to its optimum capcity it did a 7-8 hr ride using tcx course and about 1/2 of backlit (on low) with at least a third battery charge left
Having said it was cheap it did require formatting the drive and re-installing the folders (which is easy) and installing a firmware that didn't auto shut off after a while, this was 3.1 opposed to the current 3.3 and putting it into smart recording opposed to every second, though I am not sure if this fixed it, it does now work with out a flaw so far.
 
Location
Pontefract
I have a camera too - my point was that a 'phone' can do many things, but a GPS unit cannot. And a spare camera can't hurt :smile:
My camera is almost as tough as my gps unit, and seriously if I don't take an image with my camera I won't be taking one. My tools are in a tool box my computer on a desk, gets a bit much carrying three 20" screens around, I don't need a mobile phone have no use for one. i think the last one I owned was 2010.

8388913611_30c4a82363_s.jpg M.T.B. by nigelnaturist, on Flickr

Not my bike.
 

martint235

Dog on a bike
Location
Welling
I don't disagree with your synopsis, and appreciate that many people love their Garmin - but I do get annoyed when someone asks for advice about what phone apps to get and then get bombarded with advice to buy a Garmin. It's a bit like the what Android phone should I get?....Answer - Get an iPhone 5.
That's not quite right. It's more like someone writing up and saying what kind of bread should I use to knock this nail into a bit of wood and people then recommending which hammer to buy. Current phones tend to be designed with two things in mind: photos and Facebook. As an add on they can also make calls but way down the list is navigation.

There's a lot of knowledge on these forums about a lot of things. People who cycle ridiculous distances like Ppete tend to know about navigation. I'd say it's worth listening.

[rant over]
 
OP
OP
KneesUp

KneesUp

Guru
My camera is almost as tough as my gps unit, and seriously if I don't take an image with my camera I won't be taking one. My tools are in a tool box my computer on a desk, gets a bit much carrying three 20" screens around, I don't need a mobile phone have no use for one. i think the last one I owned was 2010.

8388913611_30c4a82363_s.jpg M.T.B. by nigelnaturist, on Flickr

Not my bike.
The best camera is the one you have with you :smile:
 

mrandmrspoves

Middle aged bald git.
Location
Narfuk
That's not quite right. It's more like someone writing up and saying what kind of bread should I use to knock this nail into a bit of wood and people then recommending which hammer to buy. Current phones tend to be designed with two things in mind: photos and Facebook. As an add on they can also make calls but way down the list is navigation.

There's a lot of knowledge on these forums about a lot of things. People who cycle ridiculous distances like Ppete tend to know about navigation. I'd say it's worth listening.

[rant over]

A wise man always listens to advice but never blindly follows it!

I can't help feeling that sometimes there is a bit of snob value attached to ownership of a Garmin and similar products. Cycling is many things to many people and most cyclists can enjoy their cycling without cadence sensors, heart rate monitors and the likes.
 
Top Bottom