Arch said:
I think it's actually more like a student found out he could ask for a pint of ale while sitting an exam, and the porter brought him one, then fined him for taking an exam improperly dressed, because he wasn't wearing his sword...
You may well be right, there, Arch, your version sounds more plausible and I certainly heard this only at about thirteenth-hand (and no, I was
not the student referred to)!
There was another similar story pertaining to Oxford, too good not to pass on even if it is an urban myth ... "No sport may be practiced in the High [High Street]
except archery" And so on to the student who set up a target in the midst of the traffic, got a bow and arrows and began practicing. Up steps the Proctor and fines him for "not wearing the appropriate attire of an archer". I think there are other odd laws relating to archery, not just Oxford and York (have you bagged your Scotsman yet)?