MacBludgeon said:
really? have had a passing curiosity over what happened as you see so many references to it.
I used to lurk over at ACF from time to time but I don't think I ever signed up.
As far as I can remember, the forum owner Sam suddenly decreed that in his opinion smileys were rather naff and he switched them off in the forum software. A lot of people didn't like the way he'd done that without consulting the membership first, and they started using text smileys instead to make their point!
;-)
Sam then decreed that text smileys "weren't allowed" either and if anyone dared to use them they would get banned, so more people got offended and started using them. He started culling members left, right and centre.
At some point he said that he'd had enough of the whole thing and disappeared for a while. Then he came back and got rid of anyone who complained about anything. The forum was dying by a combination of him chucking members out, and others leaving in disgust. Eventually they got together and created an ACF clone - YACF (Yet Another Cycling Forum).
That's more or less what happened.
It just goes to show that a successful forum is all about its members. Any forum owner who gets too big for his/her boots will quickly find themselves with a very quiet webserver!