Which Carradice

Page may contain affiliate links. Please see terms for details.
I would like to purchase a carradice saddle bag. I generally potter about on a pashley princess, for which I will not apologise, and though I have a pair of cheap panniers they're not waterproof...not at all, and are also an awkward width.

I am weighing up the barley, lowflap and the nelson.

I commute to work (only about 2 miles each way) 2 or 3 times a week, and on weekends ride to the park or what have you with my son, and have to carry the usual paraphernalia including an extra jumper etc. And a flask of hot chocolate or I get rinsed at the park cafe. I would like to go a bit further with him this summer as he is now seven and quite competent.

I don't always have to take my laptop to and from work, it's not very big, think maybe 13 inches, but it doesn't fit in my panniers in its case and, the riding position being so upright, a backpack is weirdly painful.

I do have a basket but it bumps about annoyingly despite the bracket, I don't like carrying weight up front and again, obviously, not waterproof.

I like the proportions of the barley, though it doesn't solve the laptop problem. Obviously I have read all the measurements but the extendability part of the nelson and the lowflap confuse me.

Obviously if I could go into store somewhere and buy one that would be ideal but the nearest stockist is a touch too far.

I wish carradice would place them all side by side in a photo to illustrate the difference, maybe pack them with standards objects so you could see what each could hold e.g. a paperback, an apple, a phone...it would be so helpful when distance buying.

I realise this post is long, likely illustrative of my inner saddle bag indecision monologue.
 

geocycle

Legendary Member
I use a Barley for day rides, it would do most of what you want except the Laptop. I can come back from a ride and squeeze in a small loaf of bread. For commuting I use a Cadet, the same size as the Nelson without the pockets. I fitted it with a carry strap and bagman quick release so I can use it like a smart satchel. The cadet doesn’t have pockets which could be an issue.
 
I've got a Barley and a Lowsaddle Longflap.

The Barley I used daily for years as commuter bag, no laptop. Its surprising how much you can get into one especially if you are rolling rather folding clothes. Add a Bagman Quick Release and a Shoulder Strap (I have one I got from an old fishing bag) meant it unclipped and was turned into a nifty shoulder bag very quickly.

The Lowsaddle Longflap expands by having a top flap that unfolds and allows you to stack things on top of the carrying compartment but still underneath the flap. I wouldn't carry a laptop in that place but if you had a laptop inside the main storage, you could use a drybag to have your clothes in that space instead. Though I actually think if you had the laptop in a protective case, it'd work as a divider.

I'm busy painting getting annoyed with decorating today but I'll get the bags out and take a picture later. For now this is the Lowsaddle Longflap. The flap has been extended so I can put some things underneath the flap but not in the main storage.

10576981-10154474369115604-1916057896188980180-n.jpg
 

Vantage

Carbon fibre... LMAO!!!
Never had a Barley but I did have the Pendle which is slightly bigger. I now have the Nelson Longflap. My own Chromebook is 13x9" and I've just tried it. It fits! And without having to use the flap.extension. Plus there's room for a spare inner tube, waterproofs, flask, jumper, super soaker and all sorts of other stuff plus the side pockets for tools, sweets etc.
I can't for the life of me remember the size of the pendle but I think my Chromebook would be difficult to squeeze in there.
Pics with lappy in bag...

PXL_20250222_112335851.jpg

PXL_20250222_112354894.jpg
 
So this what I'd want to take for my laptop, the device itself, power, mouse and a case. Laptop is a 13" model.
IMG-20250222-140535817.jpg

It fits in the Lowsaddle Longflap. The case is too large for it so fits awkardly, not a problem in my panniers but for a saddle bag I'd invest in a smaller protective case.
IMG-20250222-140809821.jpg

It actaully fits as well, without the case, in the Barley too. Not sure I'd want to use this though for that as theres very little room for other things and the flap won't close 100% meaning there is a risk of water getting in.
IMG-20250222-141031668.jpg
 
OP
OP
T

therustyprincess

New Member
Amazing response thank you, I have taken a gamble on the pendle, though it may not solve the laptop issue, I like to fantasise about having a job that doesn't require a laptop.

I also spotted on another thread the genius idea of using a double headed clip to attach a carradice without undoing the straps. I will report back on the success or otherwise.
 
Amazing response thank you, I have taken a gamble on the pendle, though it may not solve the laptop issue, I like to fantasise about having a job that doesn't require a laptop.

I also spotted on another thread the genius idea of using a double headed clip to attach a carradice without undoing the straps. I will report back on the success or otherwise.

Welcome to the Carradice Club lol And look out for the signature on the inside of your bag as to who made it.

What's the double headed clip method BTW?
 
Top Bottom