Turbo - Magnetic AND Gel?

Page may contain affiliate links. Please see terms for details.

Sittingduck

Legendary Member
Location
Somewhere flat
Hi

I know little about turbo trainers but have read that they are generally either magnetic OR gel. Can they be a combination of both? This one is described as having magnetic resistance but a gel roller:

TACX Sirius


Cheers,
SD
 
Don't quite know what the gel is but basically a turbo is a freely revolving roller with resistance units attached at one/both ends.

So the gel roller in this case will probably just makes things slightly quieter or smoother.

The resistance is either magnetic or fluid (these use oil and a fan to provide the resistance).
 
Any recommendations on a turbo trainer? I was looking at the Cycleops magnetic on recently.

Various reviews here.

Having used a Tacx I would have no hesitation in buying another - mind you I didn't have to build it up from the flat pack!

I'd advise getting one with as much maximum resistance as poss.
 

Fiona N

Veteran
There are turbos with two 'resistance systems'. The Cateye turbo had both a fan (like a Concept II rowing machine) which gives resistance according to the speed your back wheel is turning at, thus is s very good simulation of the wind resistance of normal cycling. But it also has a electro-magnetic system which can also be switched in and gives a steeped resistance which is equated to increasing the gradient of the road. My specific model gave gradients of 1, 2, 3, 5, 7 and 10 degrees which felt pretty much appropriate.

The gel roller is, as someone else noted, something to reduce the noise of a hard tyre on a metal roller.
 
OP
OP
Sittingduck

Sittingduck

Legendary Member
Location
Somewhere flat
Okay - so sounds like I have ordered a magnetic resistance trainer with gel roller to reduce noise then. That'll do me, as long as its fairly quiet!

Cheers,
SD
 

screenman

Squire
Hope you have a round back wheel or that the roller is sprung loaded, otherwise they can feel a bit choppy. On my second cs-1000 in about 16 years awesome piece of kit.
 

jimboalee

New Member
Location
Solihull
There are turbos with two 'resistance systems'. The Cateye turbo had both a fan (like a Concept II rowing machine) which gives resistance according to the speed your back wheel is turning at, thus is s very good simulation of the wind resistance of normal cycling. But it also has a electro-magnetic system which can also be switched in and gives a steeped resistance which is equated to increasing the gradient of the road. My specific model gave gradients of 1, 2, 3, 5, 7 and 10 degrees which felt pretty much appropriate.

The gel roller is, as someone else noted, something to reduce the noise of a hard tyre on a metal roller.

A set of rollers should have a flywheel, which causes the drive wheel to remain spinning when you stop pedaling. It is weighted so the drive wheel's speed reduces similar to when the vehicle is rolling along a flat road on a calm day. Inertia simulation.
A set of rollers should have a device ( in Fiona's case, a fan ) which increases the load on the rollers as the drive wheels speed increases. This is called "Road Load Simulation" or RLS in the car testing world. It is a MUST.

A good set of rollers should have some extra braking mechanism to simulate a gradient. This can be a second air fan which is adjustable, swishing water in a barrel, magnets, an Eddy current asborption dynamometer or a DC or AC Dynamometer.

A really good set of rollers will use an AC dynamometer to simulate inertia, RLS and gradient which follows a pre-programmed distance/grade schedule.
But alas, these cost thousands of pounds.
 
What Tacx model do you have?

I got a Tacx Flow off another CC'er (less the £150 computer and Skyliner front wheel support which had been nicked).


They are about £300 but to be honest I would just go for a basic model without the computer unless you are really serious about wattages etc.
 
Top Bottom