Shoes, glorious shoooooes.

Page may contain affiliate links. Please see terms for details.

lejogger

Guru
Location
Wirral
I've been cycling with racing pedals and cleats for around 4 years. I started off with a cheapo pair of Pearl Isumis which did a job, but when I upgraded my bike I bought a set of dhb road shoes. I've used them for everything since - that's two and a half years of touring, commuting, club rides, time trials etc, (quite a lot of miles) and now, they look a bit scruffy, the heels are wearing, and more than anything, they smell a bit whiffy. They've got wet and dry many times, and for some reason that makes them smell like the neighbours cat uses them as a urinal.

So for a few weeks I've considered replacements. So here's my first question (as it was my first thought), should I keep my smelly existing shoes for winter/commuting and buy a really nice pair for club rides and any races (you know, carbon soles, ratchets and all that jazz), or should I be buying a really nice pair for all uses again?

My thinking is because I tried on a pair of 2012 Specialized either Expert or Comp road shoes, and when I put them on it was like snuggling my foot into a basket of kittens. I don't think my feet have ever been so comfortable - the Boa rotary closing mechanism was surprisingly excellent.

I know it's a lot of money to spend on shoes (circa £150) and you'd want to keep them nice and save them for best, but if I'm doing 70% of my riding either in less than ideal conditions or on my commute then why would I not want my feet to be comfortable all the time?! Surely there's more benefit to using your good shoes daily? If i only saved them for club rides in the summer would I really be getting value?

I've even thought of buying a new pair of the cheap dhbs (around £40) for winter and commuting AND a nice set of best, but again, why whould I be putting up with less comfortable shoes for the majority of my riding?

So what do you guys all do? Any advice?
 

Lee_M

Guru
if you can afford them and want them buy them

you may get knocked down by a bus tomorrow..... but at least you'll have nice shoes

:laugh:
 

Zakalwe

Well-Known Member
I've got a fairly cheap pair of Spesh shoes with SL cleats attached for my bad weather bike, and a nice pair of Sidi's with Keo cleats for the good bike.
 
OP
OP
lejogger

lejogger

Guru
Location
Wirral
I've got a fairly cheap pair of Spesh shoes with SL cleats attached for my bad weather bike, and a nice pair of Sidi's with Keo cleats for the good bike.
Which is what I was going to do... but then I realised that if I bought good shoes for the good bike now, I wouldn't actually wear them until next spring! I suppose I could just keep my eye out for any bargains...
I suppose it's only the same as having a good bike and a winter bike. Essentially the good bike is rarely used, but you feel the benefit from all the training on the heavy slow one when you do get out on it. It just feels odd having that attitude with shoes. I want my feet to be comfy all the time!
 
OP
OP
lejogger

lejogger

Guru
Location
Wirral
What's stopping you riding the good bike today? Glorious 14 degrees here, no chance of rain ;)
Well commuting is nearly always done on the commuting bike... it's only on very special occassions that I carbon to work...
Nice day here too, but was 4 degrees this morning when I set off. Gritters have been out, which means salt on the road. Salt + Carbon = melted bike and components ;)
 
Top Bottom