Back to basics -
Your winter bike and summer bike should be like siblings, the winter bike able to accept the summer bike's castoffs. That way when you fancy a bit of bling spending on the pride and joy, and you will, the winter bike gets an upgrade at the same time.
The only way to do this is to keep all the essentials compatable, basically the same speed and manufacturer. That might be a little dearer originally, in the long term it'll be loads cheaper. For example my chains go through three bikes before the bin, my best bike gets the clean shiney one for a couple of thousand miles, then the tourer gets another few thousand miles use out of it, then the SS runs it till it breaks.