Ok looks like defy. How come everyone rates defy's over treck's?
I do not think they do , its just that responders happen to own defys and like them
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/66602/66602cb363a07b9b6def0c18671ec4582d8d312d" alt="Grin ^_^ ^_^"
, there is not much to choose between them in reality and the frame geometries that they use for their build will suit some more than others but good fit can sort a lot of that out .
Its true that some frames are more compliant or stiff in certain areas but you should not get a dog from any of the major brands .
Just wait till the spesh allez boys get on and start raving , i personally ride a baordman and think its the business and they always get very high scores for quality , ride and equipment levels .
Best thing to do before spending any more money is to try bikes out and see what floats your boat before you decide.
Members on heres always rave about the triban 3 from decathlon if you can get to a store try them out as they offer as cycling active says a build quality and spec that rivals bikes costing 2-3 times as much.