You're really going round in circles trying to choose that new bike aren't you!
Yep

. Random selection works for me. If I'm riding a cheap, half-wrecked Carrera and enjoying it I'm sure to prefer anything that's better.
Basically I'd like carbon. But the budget (Ridgeback +£200) won't stretch.
I'd also like 105/Ultegra.
And a decent set of wheels.
Oh, and a non-standard brand.
And I'd like it before the end of February.
And I
may have found it. Just need to sort out the order and also sweet-talk
Evans into letting me cancel the order and taking the Ridgeback unopened. Which I'd then sell as unused.