My Transport Manifesto - Lord Adonis

Page may contain affiliate links. Please see terms for details.

dellzeqq

pre-talced and mighty
Location
SW2
interesting stuff on cycling, but we wait in vain for some bright spark to connect development patterns and settlement types to transport. And the acceptance of journey times at 1.1 hours is pretty silly. It all smacks of transport being in some policy ghetto.
 

Bollo

Failed Tech Bro
Location
Winch
Much of the pro-cycling and rail sentiments are all to the good, but these are yet to be crushed under the Juggernauts of pot-to-piss-in public finances, a largely pro-car press and their lumpen-readership, the car production and road transport lobbies and a dismembered and soon to be de-subsidised rail network.

I'm not optimistic.
 

domd1979

Veteran
Location
Staffordshire
The other major flaw is the assumption that we need to keep providing more capacity for roads and airports, then after increasing traffic volumes we're apparently going to achieve some magical low carbon transport system. Er....

Lots of waffle about electrifying more of the rail network, which could be a good thing, but no-one's declared where Network Rail are going to purchase their electricity from.

5 million notes to improve cycle parking - at 10 major stations. Probably no bad thing, but its arse backwards when most people start their journey at a small station and probably have no requirement for a bike at the city centre station end. Seems most of that money will go to London as usual. In the next sentence he then goes on to admit that car parking is being expanded at stations, which in most cases only serves to generate more traffic.

Fair amount of crap about interchange at stations. Usual shining examples of integration wheeled out - invariably in those areas where traffic restraint is politically easier to achieve. Proper bus/rail integration will never happen unless there is a fundamental change towards regulation of bus services. The powers in the Local Transport Act in this respect are largely a waste of space as any attempt to invoke them can be objected to by operators who just have to say their commercial interests are threatened, in which case the act says you then have to leave them alone.


dellzeqq said:
interesting stuff on cycling, but we wait in vain for some bright spark to connect development patterns and settlement types to transport. And the acceptance of journey times at 1.1 hours is pretty silly. It all smacks of transport being in some policy ghetto.
 

srw

It's a bit more complicated than that...
domd1979 said:
Probably no bad thing, but its arse backwards when most people start their journey at a small station and probably have no requirement for a bike at the city centre station end.

You wouldn't say that if you'd seen Marylebone recently. Reasonably* secure bike parking, inside the ticket barriers - and each time they extend it it fills up quicker than you can say "I hate the tube at rush hour".



*But not secure enough to stop some little bugger walking off with a brand new Brooks. You get a better class of thief - armed with an Allen key - commuting to Buckinghamshire.
 

Davidc

Guru
Location
Somerset UK
I think the key cycle bit of the speech was; "Cycling has for too long been the Cinderella of transport policy – adored but neglected, when in fact it ought to be central to our thinking and planning if we are serious about a low carbon and healthier future."

Self evidently correct, but will we see action?

I'm not convinced that the railways in Britain can ever deliver. The damage done by the man from the petrochemical industry was too huge, and the fragmentation caused by the franchising system has added to its problems. The electrifications mentioned should have happened in the 1950s, and should include the whole of Wales and the line to Penzance.
 

Bollo

Failed Tech Bro
Location
Winch
FWIW, Lord Adonis is about to be interviewed about the problems with the east coast franchise. Now what was that about a fast, modern, integrated and value-for-money rail system?
 
Top Bottom