They all get good reviews by roadies who use these tyres routinely. Don't expect the level of puncture protection afforded by thicker commuting tyres, and you might find plenty of people saying steer clear of one brand because they had a spate of punctures - it happens to them all.
FWIW I have GP4000 and GP4000S on all my bikes. Miles better than Gatorskins for rolling resistance. I only seem to puncture when I go out with my old school....so I expect to have one on Wednesday