After my broken hip ... how am I doing? Advice needed

Page may contain affiliate links. Please see terms for details.

eml1909

Active Member
Hi all,

I haven't been on a bike since I was a kid, but I started commuting to work in January this year. I'm 37 years old (male), 5"8 and almost 15 stones (so very overweight). I have a Spcialized Sirrus Elite 2011 (hybrid). I'm trying to get fit and lose weight.

I didn't ride at all from mid-Feb to mid-May as, unfortunately, I had a serious accident when I used clipless pedals for the first time. The bike store (Evans) hadn't set the clips up properly - they were set to the *tightest* setting, rather than the *loosest* setting which made it impossible for me to unclip ... so I fell off my bike with a major THUD! I fractured my hip and, after the insertion of 3 screws, I spent 3 months on crutches.

But undeterred I got back onto my bike ... and I wanted your advice about how I'm doing. Thankfully, the broken hip (although not fully healed) doesn't seem to affect my cycling (so I can't "blame" my performance on my hip).

I'm now riding approx. 3 or 4 days per week (i.e. 6 or 8 journeys) - I'm not fit enough to do it every day (rest day in the middle of the week and no riding at the weekend). It's an 8 mile commute. I'm really enjoying it, which is the most important thing. Last night I did the commute in a record time (for me) of 40 mins (riding time), averaging just under 12 mph. There's one relatively steep climb in the middle of the ride (1.6 mile stretch with an increase of 250ft), but it's downhill after that. Further details of the route can be viewed here: http://www.mapmyrun....s/view/43343446 . My start elevation is 94 ft; my maximum elevation is 423.0 ft and there is an overall gain of 387.0 ft.

I certainly feel as though I have improved over recent weeks, but I really don't know how much room there is for further improvement - I feel like I'm reaching a peak and don't think I'll be able to do it much fast than that. Of course, there's room for *some* improvement, but I find it hard to believe that I could do the ride in less than, say, 38 minutes.

I thought I was doing quite well, but when I read other threads on here, it makes me feel that I'm going at a snail's pace! Don't get me wrong, I'm not looking to enter next year's Tour de France, but I'm wondering whether this is really slow - judging by other people's experiences, I'm doing it very very slowly. I do realise that speed is a relative concept, but I'd really like to know what more experienced cyclists make of my stats.


I'm also wondering whether I should have bought a road bike. I love my hybrid but wonder whether a road bike would have been better. It's hard to imagine that it would affect my overall speed very much ... after all, the speed comes from the legs (not the bike!) and the extra weight is to be found on my stomach (not the bike!). Also, the thought of dropped handle bars does't hugely appeal to me - I like the riding position of my Sirrus (although, to be fair, I haven't tried a road bike so perhaps I would like the riding position). The truth is, having spent almost £700 on my bike (including all of the extra bits and bobs), I'm not keen to get rid of it. Also, I use panniers, which may not be suitable for a road bike...

I'm pleased to say that, having cut down on my calorie intake and alcohol consumption, my trousers are slowly but surely beginning to feel a bit looser, but I wish that the changes to my body were a bit quicker and more noticeable!

Anyway, any thoughts/suggestions/advice you could give me would be great. in particular: how do you think I am doing and should I be aiming for a much faster time? would I benefit from a road bike? any tips about weight loss?

Thanks for reading and thanks for any advice!
 

sdr gb

Falling apart
Location
Mossley
Hi eml1909.

In 2007 after a low speed crash, I broke my femur and smashed my hip into 5 pieces. I had a Dynamic Hip Screw installed to pin everything back together. My time off the bike was longer than yours (7 months) as I wanted to make sure the hip had fully healed before I started on the bike again.

You say the hip hasn't fully healed yet, Did your Dr give the go ahead to start cycling again ?

As for your ride stats, don't worry about speed and times at the moment. They will improve as you get fitter and the hip heals more(don't forget, your body is still in recovery from a major injury). When I started back, my rides were roughly 5-10 miles long and I averaged around 10-12mph for them. Once the muscles regain full strength, you'll find that your speeds will increase and you'll fly up the hill.

Now for the bike question. You say that drop bars don't appeal to you, so for the time being, stick with your hybrid as you find the position comfortable and a comfy rider is a happy rider. If in the future you wish to get a road bike, either borrow one from a friend to see how you get on or test ride one from your LBS to see if the position agrees with you. Some road bikes can have panniers attached but also look at touring bikes as these are better suited to mounting panniers. If and when the time comes to get a new bike, start a "What Bike" thread and the good people on here will offer advice.

Other people on here will give you advice on losing weight as no matter what I eat, I never weigh more than 9.5 stone so I can't really give you any advice.
cool.gif


Enjoy your cycling and as I said above, don't worry about speeds and times, they'll start moving in the right directions soon enough.
 
OP
OP
eml1909

eml1909

Active Member
Thanks for your words of encouragement! Yes, the Dr said it was fine for me to start cycling and it doesn't seem to "stir up" my hip at all, which is good.

I think I will take a road bike for a test ride at some stage soon (I like the look of the Specialized Allez Elite. (I hadn't really thought about a toring bike and I'm not entirely sure what the difference is between that and a road bike or a hybrid bike, but I'll look into it).


My journey to work is much easier than my journey home - it's much flatter and has very few inclines at all. This morning I did the journey in averaging 23km/ph or 14m/ph.

Hopefully my time / performance will continue improving.....
 
One of th great things about cycling is that there is no "right" way.

I am faster on some days than others, but I started to analyse my rides. WHat I did find out fromthe figures is that actually my riding was pretty consistent. The work journey is 34 minutes (give or take two minutes)ravelling time, but the variation was due to other factors. My "stopped time" varies from 5 - 18 minutes depending on which junctions I stop at.

The biggest aid I found at first was a heart rate monitor. It enabled me to set a standard and stay there, this did help. Then I bought a Garmin Edge and this was even beter - I can now look at a ride and see where I was slow or fast. The "partner" also lets me keep up to the performance on a good day!

All of this was done on the same bikes.

It is the f you put in that will bear fruit. If you raise the heart rate you will burn more calories and that is achievable on any machine. A racer will be faster, but less effort so could be counter-productive. Stick with the one you are comfortable with at this stage
 
Top Bottom