1st Post: Which of these bikes should I buy?

Page may contain affiliate links. Please see terms for details.

thechangingman

New Member
Hello there!

I stumbled across this site while trawling information about possible bikes to get involved in longer rides and maybe even doing a bit of Audax.

Its a long ol' story, but suffice to say that I am a little bit late to all this (I am 44 and haven't cycled properly for over 15 years until becoming a 'born again biker' earlier this year...)

My wife bought me a nice, simple hybrid so that I could do a bit of road, do a bit off-road and see how I got on. Well, I have absolutely loved it and after a lot of initial off-roading I have come to the firm conclusion and realisation that its the road for me...

Towards this end I am now looking at entry-level road bikes but ones on which speed is not the prime requisite, but rather the ability to spend potentially long hours in the saddle.

I did 102 miles a few weeks ago on my hybrid (something I really wouldn't recommend...) but it really solidified my desire to be doing longer distances.

I have brought my short-list down to two bikes now.

I would VERY much welcome any comments, advice and insight any of you might have about the respective benefits and pitfalls of these two.

Firstly, I have just test-ridden the really very lovely Specialized Secteur Sport 2010 and although it was a rotten, windy day it was clear that this was a nice piece of kit. I found it comfortable, light and more than fast enough to meet my needs. I'd be exaggerating to say that it 'ate up the bumps' but it wasn't as stiff as I'd imagined it might be. Its comes in, brand new, at £650 and my LBS has thrown in £50 worth of accessories.

The second bike is a second-hand Specialized Tarmac Comp (2006/7) that is in immaculate (almost unused) condition. A friend of a friend bought it for triathalons that never came to pass and so it is pristine. It has SPDs, an odometer and a couple of other bits and bobs. It'll cost me £600 if I get it.

So, the new or the used? The carbon or the aluminium? The speed or the comfort?

Given that I will be doing about 50 miles a week and with bigger weekend rides, hopefully leading onto 200km Audax adventures what do you more experienced riders think is my best bet?

Assume I know nothing and you'll be at my level and thanks in advance for taking the trouble to help me - its appreciated...
 

andyfromotley

New Member
They are both fine bikes. If it was me i would go for the tarmac, provided it was a perfect fit. If it isnt get the new one ensuring that it fits perfectly. I think is the single most important criteria for someone like yourself looking to do longer rides. The tarmac should be plenty comfy enough for long rides unless you are really looking for an armchair type ride.

Whichecer you choose, enjoy.

andy
 
I'd jump at the Tarmac. It will be slightly smoother on the road and has(I think) a 105 Groupset which is a lot better than the one fitted to the secteur.

If comfort is a premium I'd stick to 32 spoke wheels and then if you find that the toll on your energy is a relatively greater discomfort change to a decent set of wheels.
 
Top Bottom